Famous Five1 Sep 2022 19:59
Sir Mark Moody-Stuart – ex Shell chairman
Sir Frank Chapman – ex BG boss
Steve Holliday – ex National Grid
Malcolm Brinded – ex chairman of the Energy Institute
Mark Carne – ex Network rail boss & ex Shell
Wrote to The Times today.
They point out that electricity prices now bear no relation to the cost of generation due to ties to the global gas prices, even though gas makes up less than 20% of our electricity generation. Currently, global prices are being set by Putin.
Their solution: To “immediately” cap domestic electricity wholesale prices for non-gas generators (mainly nuclear, wind and solar) while also capping “domestically produced gas prices”. Caps to be set at levels that reflect the investment risk and ensure well-run energy producers are profitable and want to continue investing in the energy transition. As for the imported gas chunk, the government would subsidise the difference between the market price and the cap, as proposed by Cornwall Insight, paid for via electricity bills or taxation.
Yes, owners of older wind and solar plants may moan. They’ve been lucking out via old-school contracts based on “renewable obligation certificates” rather than “contracts for difference” which return excess profits above a strike price to the Treasury. But, as Carne says “they are making returns vastly above their original business plans” and the government should tell them to sign up to a new deal or face a windfall tax. Ministers may ghave to compensate for hedging losses or contracts sold forward – typically in place for a year or less.
This would materially reduce the impact of the energy crisis on the UK while lowering inflation at source. Reducing energy prices in the first place is far more effective than targeting handouts after the fact. If five energy heavyweights can spot that, you’d hope the next PM can, too.
*will EPL happen? Is AB a genius for avoiding gas? Explains HBR's struggles to a point. These guy's have influence and contacts. Liz Truss may listen.