Tesla struggles with Regulations28 May 2019 10:23
TECHNOLOGY INTELLIGENCE
Tesla owners call on EU to repeal ‘crippling’ new self-driving rules
By Olivia Rudgard in San Francisco
TESLA fans are calling on European authorities to repeal restrictive self-driving rules that they say “cripple” the company’s Autopilot system.
Owners are complaining about changes to the flagship driver assistance system, which puts stricter limitations on turns and lane changes.
Tesla’s Autopilot system has been used on European roads as part of its earlier car models for almost four years, but the California-based company has recently had to update its systems to comply with new UN regulations that were adopted by the EU last year.
A petition calling on UN lawmakers to stop “stifling” the programme has attracted almost 4,000 signatures, and drivers claim the most recent update has limited the turning abilities of the Autopilot system, leading it to abandon manoeuvres halfway through if the turn angle gets too tight.
Tesla’s own note to customers states that the update “may reduce Autosteer’s ability to complete sharp turns”.
The company regularly updates the car’s systems remotely when drivers are connected to the internet, introducing new features and modifying the car’s abilities.
Some European Tesla drivers are opting not to upgrade to the new system as a result of the criticism. “You just can’t have a driver assistance system that suddenly gives up control in the middle of a manoeuvre,” said one driver on a Tesla forum.
Olly Ryan, a British YouTuber who regularly posts videos showing off the car’s abilities on his channel Tesla Driver, said he found the new features “less than impressive”.
“I feel they are unneeded and have actually forced a more unsafe version of Autopilot to be pushed out due to rushed and inappropriate new regulations by the EU, which is unfair on Tesla,” he said.
The regulations adopted by the EU are part of UN safety rules, which apply to cars that have level two automation – a stage at which drivers are still supposed to be paying full attention and in control of the car. Jean-Isaias Rodriguez, chief of the information unit at the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, said: “It is good for safety that Tesla implements these limits,” adding that safety was the “first priority” of the UN’s working group on vehicle automation.
He said the turn limitations were “for safety reasons”, adding that the rule “does not sound very stringent or unreasonable”.
The rules also say that Autopilot must change lanes within five seconds of signalling, a move that Mr Rodriguez said was designed to make sure the driver was paying attention during the entire manoeuvre. “Allowing a longer time would be at the cost of safety for the driver, since drivers would stop carefully monitoring the manoeuvre if the manoeuvre lasts too long, and for cars behind, which would expect an imminent lane change that may fail to take place,” he said.
The European Transport Safety Council said Tesla cou