RE: Absolute Disgraceful Proposal21 Jul 2025 13:25
I think it's basically neutral. Mr Mellon has been trying to pick up as many shares as possible. (Or rather, as someone has pointed out, a very junior member of his investment team is doing it with the petty cash...) This is because he's been able to hoover them up for 2p per share, when the NAV is at least 6p per share, i.e. assuming he will eventually be able to liquidate the portfolio, he'll make 3x his money. I think this is why he didn't get rid of Ed sooner - as Ed has kept the SP low by not investing in anything.
Now that he's bought up most of the floating stockpile of shares, he's ditched Ed and offered to buy up as many shares as possible through the Treasury, to increase his overall percentage holding and boost NAV / share.
So, if you hold onto your shares whilst others sell, you'll be in a stronger position. But then, by that logic, nobody will sell and nothing will change...