RE: Shares diluted by 6.1%31 Oct 2024 20:23
Terry, you're right, it does need a slide rule.
The EBITDA of the acquisition is stated as $19m. Assuming no improvement in prices realised and no change to the forecast net purchase price then time to payback is about 3 years (less than the 3.5x quoted multiple).
That's how they were able to part fund with debt and part with equity. Obviously the same money would not have been available for a share buy back, and even if it was the time to payback via improved cash flow per share on share purchases is a fair bit further out. I fact given interest rate on debt finance being broadly the same as the current dividend rate, unless the company was debt free buy backs would make no improvement to cash flow at all short term.
(Imagine a company with a valuation of $100m paying a 10% dividend borrows $10m to buy back shares. In cash flow terms the company would be paying either the same $10m in dividend to fewer shareholders, or will have reduced the dividend cost in line with reduced mkt cap. It will now also be paying 9-10% interest on the $10m loan. In cash flow terms the company is either worse off or at best more or less even. It has not increased it's income and has either higher or similar outgoings.
If the same company borrows $10m to buy $5m of extra income, and uses the extra income acquired to pay down the debt in the first two years, then by year 3 the company is making an extra $5m a year and in the same income / debt position otherwise.)
Modelling this out in terms of production degradation and actual returns and interest rates is harder, particularly as production price varies, and overheads get reduced, but the general principle applies.