RE: Re: Holding Changes10 Nov 2021 09:16
Mommur,
"Thoughts on share buyback ??..."
You're having a laugh are you not, is it April already .... buyback, absolutely NO, NO,NO .... imo
Never really seen evidence that SBB's have any long lasting +ve effect on a SP, particularly one on AIM.
How much of 'our' cash are we willing to let the board 'waste' on SBB, £5m, £10m ...£50m, slippery slope imo.
For me SBB is total and utter admittance of failure of our board to make our cash work .... which, tbf looks to be proven right as we have done nothing in terms of acquisitions since BKR and what we have done (BKR / Columbus / Rowallan) has always gone well over budget or ended in failure. SBB are an easy and lazy way to 'show' SH our board is actively managing our interest .... lol.
Since 2016 we have issues ~5,000,000 free shares as part of LTIP / ESIP , so buying those back would cost ~£10m, much more than our recent dividend payments to us SH ( millions more nil-cost options btw lay in wait to be issued ) .... I would much prefer the £10m be issued as dividend than wasted on SBB. Better still stop all LTIP / ESIP and have our board dip into their own pockets to buy shares rather than get freebies. I'm sure an RNS stating ACW et al buying a decent amount would do more for the long-term support of SP and having their own skin in the game.
The only way a SBB would gain my vote was if our company was materially undervalued and the shares were put into treasury to facilitate an acquisition. Clearly, the SP would need to rise significantly above purchase price for their to be any gain. If anything, time for SBB was last year when we were sitting at 120p/s with £100m cash in the bank, not now just as the SP has come off an all time high.
Also, SBB are an artificial way to manipulate EPS .... so appearing to make the company more valuable to SH and investors.
Of course, all this assumes we use our own cash and not debt for the SBB, which is another ballgame altogether.
RETURN CASH TO SHAREHOLDERS .... NOT SHARE BUYBACKS
aimo & dyor