RE: The question is…..2 Oct 2022 19:09
UK
proactive logo
Aviva, M&G and other blue-chip life insurers can withstand short-term shocks, says analyst
12:38 Thu 29 Sep 2022
Oliver Haill
View
Aviva PLC
LSE:AV.
Aviva PLC -
Aviva staff
Falls in life insurers Legal & General Group PLC (LSE:LGEN) and Aviva PLC (LSE:AV.) since the misfiring mini-budget have been driven by news about margin calls for UK pension schemes but UBS analysts played down the risks for the listed companies as "manageable".
Since chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng's fiscal announcement last Friday there has been a sharp rise in long-term UK interest rates and a weakening of the pound versus the US dollar, which has resulted in the UK life insurance sector underperforming the wider insurance sector and the market, the analysts said.
The life insurance sector saw one of the largest share price drops on Wednesday, with L&G and M&G PLC (LSE:MNG) both down 16% over the past five days, Phoenix Group Holdings PLC (LSE:PHNX) 12.3% and Aviva also 12%.
Margin calls and collateral
News about UK definite benefit pension schemes facing margin calls on liability driven investment (LDI) strategies drove the sell-off, as falling gilt prices caused mark-to-market losses that would have required much-increased collateral cover.
Pension schemes use interest rate derivatives to protect against interest rate falls and/or to match long-term liabilities, which are in-the-money when interest rates are low but after the sharp rise in interest rates, floating rate payments increased, requiring pension funds to post large sums of collateral.
Initial estimates of potential margin calls for the pensions industry are greater than £1bn since the budget announcement, driven primarily by the recent rise in interest rates, but analyst Nasib Ahmed said insurers "hold greater liquidity buffers to withstand short-term shocks, in our view".
"Whilst life insurers also use similar techniques to manage market risks, we see margin calls and liquidity impacts as relatively more manageable for our coverage," said Ahmed, while also adding it was "positive" for the sector that the Bank of England stepped in with its emergency bond-buying program to stabilise the gilt market.
As life insurers do have large sums of liabilities on their balance sheets and invest in derivatives to hedge interest rate, currency and inflation risk, the analyst said while he does not see negative impacts from collateral calls from higher inflation, he does expect some collateral calls due to interest rate and forex hedges.
Noting that there are over 5,000 pension schemes in the UK, some smaller schemes are "potentially lacking expertise and/or assets to adequately manage liquidity risk", the analyst said.
But for the four blue-chip life insurers, "we see margin calls on interset rate swaps as most onerous for liquidity positions given collateral is typically posted as cash".
"Margin calls on FX hedges can be met with corporate bonds (depending on the