RE: The offer27 Sep 2020 21:30
IMO it's a question of the actual value of each company. The share price or current MCAP of DELT or IOG is not what they will be discussing /considering, it will be the actual value of each company. Each company will have their opinion on their own value, the value of the other party and they will come to agreement through due diligence and negotiation.
So what IMO is reasonable valuations for both?
The latest Arden report on IOG, released at the time of the recent license awards had a NAV of £130m for IOG, commenting:
"No change to forecasts or valuation. We have not yet added the new awarded fields into our NAV."
Given the early stage of development of the new licenses I do not anticipate the IOG NAV moving markedly on these additions.
The latest Allenby report on DELT released around the same time and taking into account the upragdes on Sellene had a risked NAV of £192m for DELT, commenting:
"We have upgraded and revised our presentation of Deltic’s risked valuation to focus on the three most advanced projects. For these we now show the valuations using the same valuation quotient of $5/boe as in the success case. For the other earlier stage projects, we have used $2/boe. The risked valuation across the portfolio for Deltic is now £192m or 13.7p/share. This compares with 9.8p/share previously. Our success case valuation for the three most advanced projects remains unchanged at 17.5p/share. The risked valuation on this basis is £120m or 8.5p/share. The share price reflects a very cautious view of valuation and stands at a c. 90% discount to our risked estimates. ."
Personally I think the upgraded valuation quotient on Pensicola, Sellene and Dewar from $2.5 to $5 per barrel is premature. Maintiang the Previous $2.5 valuation quotient for Pensicola, Sellene and Dewar gives these 3 a NAV of £60m. With the less developed assets accounting for £72m combined giving DELT a total NAV of £132m.
Surprisingly similar, arguably very balanced, NAVs.
IOG holders won't like the idea that DELT with no production on the horizon can be valued on equal terms with IOG. However, the high volume propsective resources DELT have on thier books do have substantial value.