Impact not Huge ???20 Feb 2024 08:49
Is this FCA investigation not going to produce large fines or penalties and pay outs? The way SP is behaving - stabilizing and moving upwards, and large volumes - points to that.
As I see , it is all about discretionary commissions (DC) charged by CBG and other lenders. The vehicle buyers came to realize that they have been overcharged after FCA banned DC in January 2021. But there is a catch. The ban is not retrospective. That is why many lenders are challenging the claims made by car owners saying that the rule was not in force for period prior to 2021. So it is not going to be easy for the FCA to award compensation. Further the lenders have not breached any rules and therefore, even if awards are made, fines or penalties will not be imposed on the lenders as they have done no wrong. Right. How much involved.
I saw in the FCA website, it says , that by banning the DC , customers would save £165 mn per year. So isn't this roughly the amount car owners will get and become a charge to the lenders. Doing the numbers , the 14 years past it would be £2.3bn. So it is not going to be tens of billions. CBG share could be a small. FT reports it would be around £110 Mn, RBC estimate, one year Dividend.
https://www.fca.org.uk/news/press-releases/fca-ban-motor-finance-discretionary-commission-models
https://www.ft.com/content/474f5c90-b336-4576-bf12-0f88d0ccde6f
GLA