RE: Chart levels3 Nov 2021 16:45
IMO and, I must stress, this is just an opinion, the last RNS (CDTA) and RNS regarding accounting treatment of the DHSC dispute are very deliberately negative. They have had an inevitable knock down effect on the SP in the short to medium term but, I believe, have been done in the long-term interest of the company and hence will, in the end, support longer-term shareholder value.
These RNS have not been targeted at shareholders but are formal markers/records. The latest, which may be trying to garner media attention too, is simply setting a record of the material costs to the company that the CTDA incompetence is having. The RNS regarding the dispute is, again, meant to show the maximum negative impact as part of the ongoing negotiations. It is as formal a recognition of the impact of the contract termination as possibly can be provided to support their stance.
So, yes, these two pieces of information will have a negative impact on the SP in the medium-term, but this is immaterial to the longer-term health of the company. All that matters is that the dispute is resolved on favourable terms to us and that this includes the maximum level of compensation possible. So, the worse the figures look, the better the compensation, and the same goes for the CTDA.
Clearly, traders will feed on this and, though I was expecting a little volatility following yesterday’s announcement, I was a little taken back by the army of trolls suddenly amassed on the board and elsewhere ready to knock this in a concerted attack for whosoever’s purposes.
Whilst no one wants to see their share value eroded day by day, we have to keep looking at the fundamentals. The current SP of 238p puts the market capitalisation at £167m. We have in the region of 100m cash in bank (not counting tax rebates, a windfall from a resolution etc), so this values the company net at 67m? Does this sound right to any of you? I’m not sure I can comprehend how ridiculous this figure appears to me but, put it this way. The value of tax rebates and dispute resolution could easily be more than this. That means, with favourable news, one could be buying the company for less than it holds in cash! Even with no revenues from a resolution, £67m is cheap. Even if revenues halve next year and again the year after, it is still ridiculously cheap.
However, I cannot see DA doing anything to support the SP until the dipste is resolved. As I’ve said before, I doubt this will happen until the new year. So, why not sell and come back in later? Because this is only my best guess regarding timing, good news could come at any time. So, like HarChris, I am willing to suffer further falls knowing that at any point this could see a huge rerate and positive bounce. I too could be wrong, but that’s the risk of investing if one wants to see potential, multiple gains.
GL to all LTH