Kraken. Never seen this before12 Mar 2019 08:38
Cairn impairment will be in the order of US$ 564 million, on a 100% basis.
So, we have two publicly traded E&P companies, with a material difference in their valuation of the same field.
Cairn said that their "estimation of Kraken 2P reserves has been reduced to reflect current performance".
ENQ, on the other side, says that they are not performing any impairment, despite of the fact that the field is currently producing less than 50% of what was originally planned. And that average production for the year will be in the 30.000-35.000 range, that is, 60-70% of original target.
Reserves are valued on a NPV basis. Even if the total amount of oil to be recovered remains the same, the lower production in the first few years will have an impact on their NPV
Two of the three companies involved in the field (Bumi and Cairn) have taken an accounting impairment, for a few hundred million dollars each (on a 100% basis).
But the operator says that there is no need to take any action in the accounting front, that all is going well.
what do you see that Mr market will think of that?
In my oppinion, without a clear and consistent explanation at the next conference call, ENQ management credibility will be seriously impaired (not punt intended) by the analysts and investors community.