RE: Omicron - who would you believe - a personal letter15 Dec 2021 05:37
Dr Angelique Coetzee is asked how many patients infected with Omicron she has seen with the most severe symptoms.
"No one," she replies. Apart, that is, from a man with HIV who had pneumonia and comorbidities.
COVID-19: Omicron variant may be 'milder' but its infection rate could be 'devastating', expert warns
"I haven't seen any COVID-19 pneumonia and neither have my colleagues," she adds.
A couple of patients she saw before her interview with Sky News were showing mild symptoms.
"They're happy, they're going on holiday," she says with something resembling a shrug. Boris Johnson is creating "hysteria", the GP who also heads South Africa's Medical Association says, adding that the UK is much better vaccinated than her country.
With tens of thousands testing positive every day, few South Africans doubt the explosive transmissibility of the Omicron variant.
Yet Dr Coetzee says the difference between Omicron and the last dominant variant, Delta, is stark.
COVID-19 passes for nightclubs and large events come into force in England as booster jabs open to all adults
Chef tom kerridge
COVID: Tom Kerridge warns 'restaurants will crumble' after hundreds cancel bookings due to new coronavirus restrictions
"Delta was terrible, it was heart-breaking. When (the patients) opened the door you just knew they were in trouble," Dr Coetzee explains.
"The next thing I had to think about was beds, oxygen, what are we going to do. At this surgery, I think in total we had 10 deaths and the patients were extremely, extremely sick."
She is asked if, three weeks into the Omicron outbreak, she has witnessed similar scenes
"No," Dr Coetzee replies.
The medic has been asked to scrutinise the UK government's response to the new strain by Westminster's science and technology committee
Britain's approach to Omicron - with predictions of one million infections by the end of the month and moving hospitals into "crisis-mode" - rankles with Dr Coetzee because she does not think the evidence supports such actions.
"They need to understand the clinical picture," she says, adding that there is a "huge gap" between "the science and what is actually happening".
"What do I give to (Omicron) patients? Do I give them the same treatment as Delta? No, you don't have to. There is no need for that."
"Do you think the UK is over-reacting?" she is asked.
"You need to take precautionary measures, you have to be prepared but don't hype it up, (don't say) that people are going to die from viral infection, that hospitals will be overwhelmed. It is better to wait and see."
...