Gold As An Emerging Market Play14 Jan 2022 08:05
Spare a thought for gold bugs, like me. Go back a year to the beginning of 2021, and the gold bugsâ reasoning was clear. Inflation was coming. With all the money-printing and fiscal stimulus across the rich world, inflation would breeze past the 2% rate the consensus was expecting at the time. From there, it would be just a short skip and a jump to higher gold prices.
As we now know, inflation did indeed breeze past 2%. But the skip and a jump to higher gold prices never happened. Gold bugs were left with the depressing spectacle of rapidly rising inflation eating into the real value of their gold holdings. To add insult to injury, gold prices actually fell. Through the second half of the year, as OECD inflation kept powering higher, gold repeatedly ran into resistance at US$1,830/oz, to end the year down -3.6%.
what went wrong? The most obvious explanation is that goldâs relationship to inflation is hardly one-to-one. Sure, over the very long term gold is an inflation hedge. But this doesnât mean the relationship holds true over every quarter, or even over every year. Instead, as Gavekal has long maintained, investors should look at gold as a derivative play on emerging markets.
Nowadays, most of the worldâs demand for physical gold comes from India, China, the Middle East and Russia. Over time, this demand for physical gold can create powerful self-reinforcing feedback loops, either to the upside or to the downside.
For example, a strong US dollar leads to tighter financing conditions across the emerging markets, and so to weaker growth. In turn, weaker growth leads to weaker demand for physical gold among poor emerging market consumers. Sometimes, liquidity conditions can even get so tight that rich Indians, Chinese or Russians are forced to cash in some of their gold holdings for US dollars. This pushes the price of gold down and leads to an even stronger US dollar. Wash, rinse, repeat.
In the upside feedback loop, strong growth in the emerging markets leads to higher disposable incomes in the local economies. Local savers put some of their money into gold, which rises in price. As the price of gold goes up, more savers part with more of their US dollars to buy gold, and the US dollar falls. In turn, the weakness of the US dollar leads to easier financing conditions for emerging market economies, which leads to stronger growth. Again, wash, rinse, repeat.
Between 2002 and 2011, the world experienced the second kind of feedback loop: emerging markets boomed and gold prices went through the roof. Since then however, emerging markets have struggled and returns on gold have been dismal, in spite of negative real interest rates and accelerating OECD inflation.
So are there any reasons gold should now emerge from its funk?
(to be continued)