RE: Putin another Peter the Great or Stalin?1 Aug 2022 12:44
It seems to me no one knows what they are talking about when it comes to the Ukraine [and probably history more broadly]
I recall being taught the History of the British Empire, by a delightful History teacher when I was young, at High School. I actually got a high distinction I was so enthralled. It is now apparent, that what he taught was marginally short of utter rubbish, but he, and we, did not know that back then. Such was the state of knowledge, .... and other things
I once worked for a most famous Mining Company, for 15 years, and was lucky to rise through the ranks to the top, technically speaking. It got taken over, as happens. Some years later, one of the former CEO's decided that the ~70 year history of this most famous company was lost or in the process of being lost, and so he commissoned a history of the company to be written, and duly appointed himself as Editor in Chief [ with the best of intentions] The book was written and edited, and I am sure edited gain, and came out as a hard cover book which looked great and will last 100-200 years. The trouble began when one read it, with the knowledge of one had lived through some of the history, and the history written was not a lot like the history experienced? HIstory is written by the winners (as we know) but in this case it was edited by one of the losers, who did not want to own up to what he had lost. So best edit the losses out. and so on and so forth.
A little later, I started another Exploration Company, which became a Unicorn (Market Cap $1b) in about 4 years! A few more years after a lot (including myself) had moved on, the new Managing Director decided that most people did not really know the history of the company, so he commisssioned a hisotry book to be written Who should write , and who should edit etc? Well it got wrote [by an Independent Journalist], and once again I got my copy, and opened the pages. Again the history written was not that similar to the history lived. Only ~20 years had transpired, and yet the history was in tatters, and despair set in.
I realised that History is such a subjective matter, and people can argue to they are blue in the face, about the "true facts"
and who really did this, and said that...
I realised that if one has so much trouble trying to catch the history of a company of 70 years old, or 20 years, what hope does one have of trying to understand what really happened to a country, in a 500 year history, with may winners and losers through those years.
I think not a lot...
Great to read the history, but believing it is another country. Not my country any more. There are more important things to do with ones few more days on the planet, than to read and argue the delusions and lies of others.
Go gold
best
the Gold Gnome.