RE: The de - fi / Blockchain revolution …21 Jan 2023 10:15
For the people who believe in the utopian hype version of DeFi, this is a good document to read; It gives comparisons between the current systems and the DeFi equivalent, but something that stood out for me was at the bottom of the table comparing traditional finance to DeFi, it says "Users assume all risks as a default, although private redress arrangements such as DeFi insurance offer some protection against losses". There are other reasons I don't buy into the hype, like the loss of Central Bank and Governmental control of currency and other things that I can't see Powers that Be allowing .
"https://wifpr.wharton.upenn.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/DeFi-Beyond-the-Hype.pdf"
When I glance through the document at the various applications and what's involved in implementing the technology, it seems far from simple to me. It'll require an army of software Engineers to maintain and manage the systems and we should just trust them, right? If you get defrauded in this decentralised utopia, or a glitch/fault somehow disappears your money into a black hole, who're you gonna call, Ghostbusters?
The document conclusion:
"Conclusion
DeFi is a new, fast-growing area. Yet it remains immature, with a variety of unresolved economic, technical, operational, and public policy issues that will be important to address. Although some protocols have attracted significant capital and the associated network effects in a short period of time, the DeFi sector remains volatile. DeFi has the potential to transform global finance, but activity to date has concentrated on speculation, leverage, and yield generation among the existing community of digital asset holders. In addition, the very flexibility, programmability, and composability that make DeFi services so novel also expose new risks, from hacks to unexpected feedback loops among protocols.
Retail investors, professional traders, institutional actors, regulators, and policy-makers will need to temper enthusiasm for the innovative potential of DeFi with a clear understanding of its challenges. Developers are actively working to address vulnerabilities and introduce new mechanisms to manage risks efficiently, but the process is ongoing. DeFi will ultimately succeed or fail based on whether it can fulfill its promise of financial services that are open, trust-minimized, and non-custodial, yet still trustworthy"
Just to add, all the serious research on DeFi appears to revolve around Ethereum, not Bitcoin.