RE: That Baron Investments Tweet6 Dec 2023 17:40
Morningstar fund analyst Robert Starkey praises Jupiter Special Situations manager Ben Whitmore in this regard: "Whitmore has continually shown the courage of his convictions in building the portfolio, which can look quite different from the benchmark at the sector and market-cap levels."
But when the value style of investing is out of favour (such as last year), these funds can struggle. The flipside, or course, is they can outperform when these stocks make headway. The FTSE AllShare is up around 9% in the year to date, and all our five funds are ahead of this.
UK large and mid-cap value stocks were badly out of favour last year, and thus represented some of the most compelling special situations opportunities in that period. But now they've caught up, any manager owning these stocks will now have weightings similar to the benchmark, which can limit the chance to outperform.
For example BP (BP.) constitutes 2.91% of the Liontrust Special Situations fund and 2.57% of the index (Jupiter Special Situations fund has 5.47% of its portfolio in BP - more than double the AllShare index). A bet on BP will have paid off this year, as its shares are up nearly 30%, although this comes after a 40% fall in 2020.
How Special are Special Situations Funds?
In most cases, the top 10 holdings of these funds vary significantly from the index. Aggreko (AGK) makes up just 0.09% of the benchmark, for example, but is the second biggest holding in the Liontrust fund.
These special situations funds are also much more concentrated than the AllShare index, which comprises 601 stocks, compared to between 42 holdings (Artemis) to 97 (Fidelity) holdings in the fund portfolios.
Will these funds remain "special" as the market continues to re-appraise value stocks? Fidelity's Alex Wright thinks the rotation back into value is still only just getting started after years of growth stocks having the upper hand. "UK equities, and in particular value stocks, continue to look very attractively valued in a global context, a hangover of prior Brexit uncertainty and the disproportionate impact of the pandemic on the domestic economy," he says.
According to Morningstar analysis, the majority of the most commonly held stocks are undervalued. These include 5-star rated Royal Dutch Shell (RSDB) and Imperial Brands (IMB), which are held by three and two funds respectively. Seven other stocks have 4-star ratings, while only four stocks have a 2-star rating.
https://www.morningstar.co.uk/uk/news/212896/what-do-special-situations-funds-invest-in.aspx