RE: Utah Core samples16 May 2024 13:52
As you guys know, my opinion has always been that Hoodoo's approach has been highly cynical: trying to waste time and money in order to extract concessions out of Heavy Sweet Oil. My research has indicated that they've tried every possible avenue to disrupt and delay with filings, appeals, etc.
Amongst which, appeals/filings/proceedings to: DOGM, DOGM Board, SITLA, SITLA Board, US Department of the Interior. No doubt state and federal court in due course, if they decide to continue trolling.
Hoodoo's business model appears to be to buy up large tracts of mineral leases — ostensibly to develop — in reality, it appears to be the exception rather than the rule.
Instead, my view Hoodoo are 'lease-squatting' land that looks like it will attract genuine companies at a later date, so they can charge a royalty without taking any real risk themselves (or force a JV where Hoodoo just contribute the land/mineral rights). I'm sure they Hoodoo offer some surveying and other data, but that frankly seems of very limited materiality.
[I coined the term 'lease-squatting' up for the sakes of illustrating the issue, as it reminds me of domain-name squatting.]
From the Utah state's perspective, the majority of their income derives from royalties on the minerals *produced* (e.g. $x per tonne/bbl/etc). The fees for the lease itself are usually not especially high.
Economically, Hoodoo's model is a kind of rentseeking, IMO.
Heavy Sweet Oil threw a spanner in the works by bypassing Hoodoo — they acquired leases on the same acreage for bituminous/asphaltic materials, and *not* the liquid hydrocarbons that Hoodoo leased in the expectation that would be what their potential "clients" would be looking for.
You'll see a more comprehensive layout of some recent information I discovered over on The Quadrise Shareholders' Forum as I can't post inline images here, but it seems quite clear to me as a non-lawyer that the SITLA leases define the substances separately.
Naturally, that won't stop Hoodoo's lawyers wasting everyone's time and money by looking for a tiny hole to crawl through.