High yield - money trap or oppurtunity12 Jan 2023 20:54
Happy New Year to all FAIRy's (!). 1of 2
I'll try to answer/give my opinion on some of the questions asked here - apologies for the tawdry response.
Firstly have to say i've been thinking about FAIR and its ilk since the update from DLG yesterday. DLG is a favourite amongst high yield seekers and whilst it demonstrates the value trap that seemingly all high yielders can be, it, to me, also demonstrated that supposedly high risk stocks such as FAIR aren't actually so high risk - especially within the context of mainstream high yielders, and being part of a wider portfolio (albeit i am top heavy with CLOs/high yielders). I hold DLG, took the hit yesterday, but still hold. Believe in it long term, but i have to say, to cancel your dividend because of one weeks poor weather smacks of poor mgmt hence i have no confidence in them, so i hold not because i believe they will turn it around, but because i believe someone will buy it to do such and i'll recoup my loss on DLG.
I say this because it brings me to answer a post about 40% drops in CLOs SP's over 5/10 years, i.e. are they value traps. Well if you are going into them for SP appreciation yes. And pretty much always. The nature of the beast is they pay out heavily regularly so they are never going to grow SP wise. I hold 5 pure UK CLOs, and 4 are down SP wise an average of 10%, 1 is up because unlike the other 4, i trade it's predictable (large) gyrations. They have been down SP wise since day 1. But the yield has more than covered that - the first i bought, BGLF, is now a free ride, and FAIR is nearing there. To answer the question, i would ask one. Would you rather a esoteric high risk stock that loses 40% over 5 years whilst paying 70% divvy, or a mainstream 'safe' stock such as DLG that has lost 50% of its SP whilst paying out 20% of it's SP?
Other High yield recommendations was a question. I don't give recommendations, just try to give insights. Yes i'm top heavy CLO's as a percentage of portfolio, but i'm actually mega top heavy high yielders. Personally i like a decent wine today, every day, not the promise of endless probably illusionary champagne some day maybe, maybe far away. so i'm a value investor first. I work on a 10/10/10/10 basis. I want a business/stock that has a yield of 10%, that has net profits of 10% (+ and ideally 20%), and a price to equity of 10. The last 10, is my strategy of targeting 10 stocks yielding 10% (ideally higher) on the basis that if 1 TOTALLY failed i would not be at at a loss. Most of my investments are high yield, most 10%+, but not all. I like solidity, continuity, not growth. that said i'm in a number of below 10%s that i believe will grow to be such. No recommendations, but in the higher range i'm invested in, believe in, MNG, DEC, GNL, IMB, JUP, RIO, NRR, PSN, PHNX, PMI, SEPL, TW., VTY and STCM. You can see many are in unloved areas (housing/fund mgmt/fossil fuels). My contrarian value style believe will come good, whilst reaping high yiel