Member Info for Bfdinvestor

My parents are dead.

I pity idiots like you who make stupid comments like that

Well maybe you should read a whole thread before you jump in with both feet Hexam on something that has nothing to do with you. In any event what you are challenging seems to be the Top Shop £180m valuation. Which as we have now ascertained is correct. Which supports my view that CWWX was posting nonsense

Glad we have cleared that up Hexam

£400m sales, nearly 18m social media following, a pre-built IT infrastructure and supply chain

Top Shop had none of those things and went for £180m

My logic is sound. You are simply claiming we both said something very specific (that Topshop was not valued at £180m) which neither of us did.

This is where you went wrong Hexam.

As I've posted multiple times that wasn't what I was saying at all. That is simply your twist

I was responding to a statement about me from CWWX, which you chose to misinterpret. Perhaps you should refrain from intervening on specific points about an individual that you clearly don't understand and then their will be less of a circus

Hexam are you really that dim

You jumped on a response from me to CWWX about his comment below. That is the nub of the debate, Top shop is simply the evidence. You really need to give it up, you are just spamming the board.

What Finley says Bfd believes……. With no evidence at all.

Very profound Ocean

But all I'm doing is responding to a simple lie from CWWX

So the basics premise of your post, in this case, is totally wrong.

As for what makes an effective liar, you guys have far more expertise than I would ever like to have so I'll leave that one with you

Hexam as I have posted multiple times, that isn't what I said at all. To reiterate for the last time, here is the original BS from CWWX that I responded to, which you felt the need to jump in on and got completely wrong. Maybe you should give it a rest too

What Finley says Bfd believes……. With no evidence at all.

Well Kat you are wrong I've had an actual buy at .7ish

Once again, CWWX, this is what you posted. I've given you the evidence and evidence that shows you are just posting garbage again. Please give it a rest

What Finley says Bfd believes……. With no evidence at all.

Amazing how all the green boxes miraculously appear.

Gotta drown out anything remotely positive

It's a bit strange given none of them have so much as a penny invested lol

The only thing I'm struggling to understand Hexam is your lack of any logic.

CWWX says I choose to believe Finley with no evidence whatsoever (rather than southcoast which is laughable in itself.

I then show the evidence that Finley used to describe the rationale for PLT sale. And you say I'm the one who is twisting.

It's quite simple really. A reasonable comparator business sells for 180m, Shein offered considerably more, and you claim you would be more than happy with a £50m price tag for PLT.

Now that's one I can't see getting through a shareholder vote

Strange Hexam, this looks very much like a £180m overall valuation to me. Care to explain why it isn't?

Why sell Topshop?

Many are probably scratching their heads at the decision to offload Topshop and Topman, and seemingly at a discount to what it paid for the businesses just three years ago.

Heartland will pay £135m for a 75% stake in the brands, with Asos holding the remaining 25%, substantially less than the £265m the online retailer paid for the pair in 2021 – although that figure did also cover its Miss Selfridge and HIIT acquisitions.

This is what CWWX said Hexam. So you don't believe that Top Shop is a valid comparator for PLT either? It seems to be a form of evidence to me

What Finley says Bfd believes……. With no evidence at all.

Strange you aren't commenting on the 1m buys Kat, just the sells

Balance and all that...

Well actually we all heard it last night

Do keep up

So are you saying Top Shop didn't sell for an overall valuation of £180m CWWX?

Now who should we believe. The poster who said suspension was nailed on or the guy with two decades experience in online retail

It's a tough choice....

Is it as nailed on as suspension apparently was southcoast

Is it as nailed on as the company not making it to the AGM was southcoast

Is it as nailed on as 5p after results was southcoast

It's strange you didn't take your own supposed advice at 39p. Keep working the CFD though, you must be desperate

Oh dear southcoast

So Finley references the value of top shop at £180m when discussing the sale of PLT and you claim it will be sold for £50m

I can't decide whether you are sad or funny

97m shares traded last Monday, 11.3M shares traded yesterday.

Where were all these massive sellers youu referred to Chaebol?

They clearly don't exist

Kat the published spread as I posted was .85p to buy and .70 to sell

Do the maths