RE: rns14 Feb 2021 10:44
As ever Quady is wrong. I did not say that once BHP were released from their restrictions we would get a bid. In fact, and as I've said previously, I have not put a timeline on things. It's simply my belief that it is inevitable - as appears to be the majority opinion both on this bb and amongst industry and City experts.
As for the 'retirement' situation, it's as plain as the nose on your face. Throughout last few years Mather has been full of pomp, and in a sense, justifiably so. People on here and specifically Quady, boldly dismissed any idea of him retiring and argued forcefully that he was 'only 68' and had plenty of juice left in the tank. But then he made the mistake of thinking he could ignore our major shareholders.
Quady and a few others thought his 'triumph' of gaining re-election demonstrated how he'd given the majors a 'bloody nose' and how they would now 'skulk off with their tails between their legs' (these words were actually used immediately after the agm.) This was a classic misunderstanding of boardroom and shareholder dynamics, particularly when a new board had only recently been appointed. The expressions of disquiet uttered by NCM publicly were a clear indication of what was to come, and sure enough it happened.
I don't believe a man like Mather had any wish whatsoever to walk away from his position. He was on the verge of a triumphant end to his career and people in those circumstances don't simply walk away. But the most telling reason of why I am right is this; if he was planning his retirement for the past 12 months, why did he put himself forward for re-election, only to 'retire' a month later? You really don't need to think much beyond this fact.
Anyway, this is history and we are moving towards a very different approach to our interaction with our main shareholders. Personally, I think Mather's NED situation may become difficult, particularly for a new CEO and, consequently, may not last long. But who knows? He may prove to be an ideal NED and will offer full support to the new incumbent, but for me, the jury's out on that one.