RE: Portfolio valuation13 Mar 2021 15:19
I've been doing some further work and thought I'd share. Some current valuations which are known because they're publicly traded:
Centennial: $88.17M, CNOR: $16.66M, Enviva: $31.55M
= $136.38M
Since the quarter end they've invested in Loanpal: $25M, Freewire: $10M, DCRB: $10M, DCRN: 0.6M I'm assuming those valuations are flat.
Cash adjusted for those investments = $49.4M
They also own: Onyx: $53M.
So far, we're at 53+49.4+25+10+10+0.6+136.38=$284.38M. The current market cap is $252.38M
Now we have the "wild cards": ILX 3, Carrier 2 and Hammerhead Resources.
Bad news on ILX 3. They've hedged 60% of expected production out to October 2024 at $44 per barrel. If those hedges are still on then we've probably really lost out.
Bad news on hammerhead: They issued further equity in 2020 and REL didn't participate. That stopped Hammerhead from going bankrupt but diluted our share of the company and reduces our upside.
Carrier 2 seems fairly trouble free, albeit they're reducing debt rather than paying dividends as they have in previous years and they've hedged 45% of 2021 gas.
I'm pencelling in: $150M for ILX 3 (that's +15M since 2020 end), $30M for Carrier 2 (that's 2x since 2020 end) and $44M for Hammerhead (that's 2x since 2020 end).
284.38+150+30+44=508.38M NAV. 252.38/508.38 = 0.496 of NAV.
So it's trading at just under 50% of NAV. Seems attractive. But there's more. Quoting from the annual report: "The Company's independent directors are supportive of the continuation of the Investment Manager's modified investment strategy for the immediate future. The independent directors will continue to monitor the Investment Manager's success in repositioning the Company's existing investment policy through the modified investment strategy. At the EGM, the Board committed to review the Investment Manager's performance and, before 31 December 2022, decide whether or not it would be in the best interests of all shareholders to request an EGM to vote on a run-off of its portfolio."
In other words, if this thing doesn't pick up sharpish we're probably going to liquidate this sucker. Oil prices could fall sharply. Or the company's discount to NAV could get even wider! Ultimately though, I think this thing is a safe bet. It either starts rallying or it's going to liquidate and shareholders should get back at least £5.50 per share. Probably more given what oil is doing. This kind of discount is untenable. It'll close one way or the other.