The latest Investing Matters Podcast episode featuring financial educator and author Jared Dillian has been released. Listen here.

Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

Pin to quick picksBP Share News (BP.)

Share Price Information for BP (BP.)

London Stock Exchange
Share Price is delayed by 15 minutes
Get Live Data
Share Price: 502.30
Bid: 501.70
Ask: 501.80
Change: -2.70 (-0.53%)
Spread: 0.10 (0.02%)
Open: 507.60
High: 510.70
Low: 501.40
Prev. Close: 505.00
BP. Live PriceLast checked at -

Watchlists are a member only feature

Login to your account

Alerts are a premium feature

Login to your account

COLUMN-BP shareholders win right to proceed in Texas: Frankel

Thu, 17th Oct 2013 14:54

(Alison Frankel is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressedare her own.)

By Alison Frankel

NEW YORK, Oct 17 (Reuters) - When Matthew Mustokoff ofKessler Topaz Meltzer & Check walked out of oral argumentsbefore U.S. District Judge Keith Ellison of Houston lastNovember, he wasn't at all sure that his case - a suit byindividual pension funds claiming to have been duped by BP -would survive BP's motion to dismiss.

The judge had expressed sympathy for holders ofLondon-listed BP common shares, whose federal securities claimsare barred by the U.S. Supreme Court's 2010 ruling in Morrisonv. National Australia Bank. Mustokoff and co-counsel from JasonCowart of Pomerantz Hufford Dahlstrom & Gross were attempting toplead around Morrison by asserting fraud and misrepresentationclaims under state and common law.

But Judge Ellison seemed to be very interested in a novelconstitutional argument BP's lawyers at Sullivan & Cromwell hadcrafted in response to the pension funds' Morrison-dodging.BP said that the funds' case violated the dormant CommerceClause as it applies to international commerce because statelaws may not exceed the bounds of federal law. Funds couldn'tassert claims under state law, according to BP, when parallelfederal-law claims were barred. Ellison was so intrigued byS&C's Commerce Clause argument that at least half of the hearingon BP's motion to dismiss the funds' two related suits,Mustokoff told me, was dedicated to that defense.

But when Ellison entered his 97-page opinion on the docketof the BP multidistrict securities litigation last Thursday, hisanalysis of the Commerce Clause argument was reduced to afootnote. The judge entirely side-stepped the question ofwhether state or common law can give U.S. investors rights theydon't have under federal law by concluding that English law -and not American common law - applies to the pension funds'claims.

ELLISON'S RULING

BP had asked the judge to choose English law, but it alsowanted him to find that an English court is the preferable forumfor a matter of English law. Instead, Ellison said that he'sperfectly capable of applying English law on fraud, which"shares so many strong similarities with U.S. law due to acommon heritage." And since the conduct at issue in the pensionfunds' case involves BP's U.S. operations - and since he'salready overseeing a class action by holders of BP AmericanDepository Shares, who are raising arguments similar to those ofthe pension funds - Ellison said it makes sense for him to hearthe funds' suits.

Ellison's ruling, as Kevin LaCroix at D&O Diary notedTuesday, is an extremely rare example of shareholders of aforeign-listed stock finding a way around Morrison. But beforethe securities class action bar starts boning up on English lawon fraud (or, as it's known over the pond, "deceit,"), there area couple things to keep in mind.

First, this case isn't a class action. It's two suits bynine pension funds that had large enough BP holdings to make itworth their while to pursue individual actions. Second, Ellisonbased his decision to retain jurisdiction on some factors thatmight not figure in other investor fraud suits. And third, BPand Sullivan & Cromwell will get at least one more chance topresent their dormant Commerce Clause argument, which couldstill erase investor claims.

'DIE-HARD BELIEVERS'

If the nine pension funds represented by Kessler Topaz andPomerantz had filed a class action instead of individual suits,their case would have been precluded by the SecuritiesLitigation Uniform Standards Act. In fact, Judge Ellisonpreviously tossed just such a class action, in which BP commonshareholders tried to evade Morrison by asserting state-lawfraud claims against the company. The pension funds, however,were determined to bring their own suits. "These people aredie-hard believers that Morrison was decided wrongly," saidMustokoff, who told me his firm has been courting funds thatwanted to try a Morrison work-around.

Mustokoff said that the pension funds also benefited frombringing both federal securities claims (as holders of ADS thattrade on U.S. exchanges) and common-law claims. Two ofMustokoff's clients opted out of the ongoing class action by BPADS holders, but asserted very similar claims in theirindividual suits; in ruling that the funds could proceed withsome of their federal securities claims as ADS holders, Ellisonrelied heavily on his previous opinion in the ADS class action.

Since those federal claims are not covered by English fraudlaw, if the judge had decided to move the funds' fraud claims toEngland, he would have had to bifurcate the suit to permit thefederal claims to move forward in Houston. But since he'soverseeing the parallel ADS class action, he said, judicialefficiency is served by him keeping the funds' case as well. "IfI had simply brought common-law claims, he may have dismissedthe case in favor of London," Mustokoff said.

His co-counsel, Jason Cowart of Pomerantz, said that the BPinvestors' case could provide a route to recovery for othershareholders with significant holdings in foreign-traded stock,but only if their claims - like those of the pension funds -have a significant connection to the United States. The parallelADS class action was one important tie between the funds' caseand U.S. courts, Cowart said, but it was also important thatsome BP statements at issue were made in the U.S. and thatclaims involved BP's safety record in its U.S. operations.

"To the extent that similar factors are in play in othercases, we would hope that a court would follow the rationale ofJudge Ellison," Cowart said.

OTHER WRINKLES

The pension funds will still have to show the falsity ofmore than a dozen alleged BP misstatements. They'll also have toshow that they relied on the misstatements when they purchasedBP shares, since there's no fraud-on-the-market presumption ofreliance in an individual action, as opposed to a securitiesclass action.

Moreover, they may not have seen the last of S&C'sgroundbreaking Commerce Clause argument. In a separate opinionon BP's motion to dismiss claims by an Ohio pension fundasserting Ohio securities laws, the judge suggested that the oilcompany would have a chance to revisit its challenge to theconstitutionality of claims that extend state law beyond thebounds of federal law. (The Ohio case includes state-law as wellas common-law claims.) If Ellison ends up deciding that theCommerce Clause bars state-law claims on securities, you canexpect BP to attempt to revive the argument with regard tocommon-law claims as well, even if they're now proceeding underEnglish law.

Ellison acknowledged that the funds' case is going to be abit of an experiment, and that he may have to consult experts onthe state of the UK's Financial Services and Markets Act of2000. There are all sorts of other wrinkles he'll have to workout, including the right to a jury and, of course, whetherEngland's loser-pays rule applies. Mustokoff told me he'sconfident that it does not.

"It's a procedural rule, not a matter of substantive law,"he said. "It's not applicable in U.S. courts."

BP counsel Darryl Libow of S&C declined to comment.

(Reporting by Alison Frankel; Editing by Ted Botha)

More News
4 Mar 2024 10:43

Jefferies upgrades BP to 'buy'

(Sharecast News) - Jefferies upgraded BP on Monday to 'buy' from 'hold' and lifted the price target to 570p from 520p.

Read more
4 Mar 2024 08:59

LONDON BROKER RATINGS: Jefferies says buy BP; UBS says buy Compass

(Alliance News) - The following London-listed shares received analyst recommendations Monday morning:

Read more
4 Mar 2024 08:55

LONDON MARKET OPEN: Review cuts Hipgnosis Songs Fund valuation

(Alliance News) - Stock prices in London opened mostly lower on Monday, as investor attention remained primarily on the release of the UK Spring budget on Wednesday.

Read more
4 Mar 2024 07:41

LONDON BRIEFING: Stocks called down; attention on UK's spring budget

(Alliance News) - Stocks in London are called to open lower, ahead of a busy week of economic news.

Read more
22 Feb 2024 09:49

LONDON BROKER RATINGS: Berenberg raises Moneysupermarket.com to 'buy'

(Alliance News) - The following London-listed shares received analyst recommendations Thursday morning and Wednesday:

Read more
15 Feb 2024 16:52

LONDON MARKET CLOSE: Stocks in green despite UK hit by recession

(Alliance News) - Stock prices in London closed higher on Thursday, after data showed that the UK economy slipped into recession in the final quarter of 2023, buoying hopes for interest rate cuts from the Bank of England.

Read more
15 Feb 2024 14:55

London close: Stocks manage gains despite UK recession news

(Sharecast News) - London markets had a mixed but ultimately positive day of trading on Thursday, despite news that the UK fell into a technical recession at the end of 2023.

Read more
15 Feb 2024 12:02

LONDON MARKET MIDDAY: FTSE 100 flat as strong start fades

(Alliance News) - The FTSE 100 tread water on Thursday afternoon, as share price declines for some of London's heavyweights offset a strong start for the index, which got a boost from Bank of England rate cut hopes.

Read more
15 Feb 2024 09:17

BP hails arrival of LNG vessel at project off Senegal and Mauritania

(Alliance News) - BP PLC on Thursday celebrated the arrival of a gas vessel offshore west Africa, which it called a "major milestone" for its project there.

Read more
14 Feb 2024 12:01

BP and Adnoc form gas joint venture in Egypt to boost capabilities

(Alliance News) - BP PLC on Wednesday said it will form a joint venture with Abu Dhabi National Oil Co in Egypt, under which BP will contribute its interests in three development concessions.

Read more
14 Feb 2024 10:27

BP and Adnoc agree Egyptian joint venture

(Sharecast News) - BP has agreed a new joint venture in Egypt with long-standing partner Adnoc, it was confirmed on Wednesday.

Read more
11 Feb 2024 09:27

PRESS: BP to book USD700 million windfall on UK tax changes - FT

(Alliance News) - BP PLC is set to book a USD700 million windfall due to UK tax changes aimed at boosting corporate pension fund investment in the economy, the Financial Times reported on Saturday.

Read more
9 Feb 2024 11:44

LONDON MARKET MIDDAY: European markets quiet heading into afternoon

(Alliance News) - European stock markets were quiet heading into Friday afternoon, as investors eye the annual US consumer price index benchmarks revisions.

Read more
8 Feb 2024 16:06

UK dividends calendar - next 7 days

Friday 9 February 
AJ Bell PLCdividend payment date
B&M European Value Retail SAspecial dividend payment date
BlackRock Latin American Investment Trust PLCdividend payment date
Braemar PLCdividend payment date
i3 Energy PLCdividend payment date
JPMorgan Multi-Asset Growth & Income PLCdividend payment date
Montanaro UK Smaller Cos Investment Trust PLCdividend payment date
Netcall PLCdividend payment date
Origin Enterprises PLCdividend payment date
Sage Group PLCdividend payment date
Schroder AsiaPacific Fund PLCdividend payment date
Tracsis PLCdividend payment date
Tufton Oceanic Assets Ltddividend payment date
Monday 12 February 
no events scheduled 
Tuesday 13 February 
Cohort PLCdividend payment date
Future PLCdividend payment date
Mondi PLCspecial dividend payment date
Wednesday 14 February 
Blackrock Frontiers Investment Trust PLCdividend payment date
Ecora Resources PLCdividend payment date
Grainger PLCdividend payment date
Oxford Metrics PLCdividend payment date
Supermarket Income REIT PLCdividend payment date
Unicorn AIM VCT PLCdividend payment date
Unicorn AIM VCT PLCspecial dividend payment date
Thursday 15 February 
Alternative Income REIT PLCex-dividend payment date
Aquila European Renewables PLCex-dividend payment date
Balanced Commercial Property Trust Ltdex-dividend payment date
BioPharma Credit PLCex-dividend payment date
BP Marsh & Partners PLCex-dividend payment date
BP PLCex-dividend payment date
Elixirr International PLCdividend payment date
Gabelli Merger Plus+ Trust PLCex-dividend payment date
GCP Asset Backed Income Fund Ltdex-dividend payment date
Greencoat UK Wind PLCex-dividend payment date
Gulf Investment Fund PLCex-dividend payment date
Hargreave Hale AIM VCT PLCdividend payment date
Henderson Opportunities Trust PLCex-dividend payment date
ICG Enterprise Trust PLCex-dividend payment date
Impax Environmental Markets PLCex-dividend payment date
Imperial Brands PLCex-dividend payment date
Invesco Perpetual UK Smaller Cos IT PLCex-dividend payment date
Invesco Select Trust PLC Global Equity Incomedividend payment date
Invesco Select Trust PLC UK Equitydividend payment date
JPMorgan European Growth & Income PLCex-dividend payment date
Knights Group Holdings PLCex-dividend payment date
M Winkworth PLCdividend payment date
Majedie Investments PLCex-dividend payment date
Mattioli Woods PLCex-dividend payment date
Mobeus Income & Growth 4 VCT PLCex-dividend payment date
Mountview Estates PLCex-dividend payment date
Murray Income Trust PLCex-dividend payment date
NCC Group PLCex-dividend payment date
NextEnergy Solar Fund Ltdex-dividend payment date
Pershing Square Holdings Ltdex-dividend payment date
PRS REIT PLCex-dividend payment date
Ramsdens Holdings PLCex-dividend payment date
Schroder UK Mid Cap Fund PLCex-dividend payment date
Shell PLCex-dividend payment date
Triple Point Venture VCT PLCex-dividend payment date
Troy Income & Growth Trust PLCex-dividend payment date
UK Commercial Property REIT Ltdex-dividend payment date
  
Comments and questions to newsroom@alliancenews.com
  
A full 21-day events calendar is provided each day with a subscription to Alliance News UK Professional.
  
Copyright 2024 Alliance News Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Read more
6 Feb 2024 17:39

London close: Stocks manage gains as oil prices rise

(Sharecast News) - London's financial markets finished with a positive performance on Tuesday, driven by encouraging data from the UK construction sector and BP's share buyback expansion.

Read more

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Quickpicks are a member only feature

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.