Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

Pin to quick picksCloudified Holdings Limited Regulatory News (CHL)

  • This share is currently suspended. It was suspended at a price of 2.25

Share Price Information for Cloudified Holdings Limited (CHL)

Share Price is delayed by 15 minutes
Get Live Data
2.25    0.00 (0.00%)
Bid:
0.00
Ask:
0.00
Spread: 0.00 (0.00%)
Market Cap: £334.79k
CHL Live PriceLast checked at - London Stock Exchange

Intraday Cloudified Holdings Limited Share Chart

Arbitration Update

30 Sep 2014 08:58

RNS Number : 9743S
Churchill Mining plc
30 September 2014
 

30 September 2014

AIM: CHL

CHURCHILL MINING PLC

("Churchill" or "the Company")

 

Arbitration Update - ICSID claim against the Republic of Indonesia

The Directors of Churchill (AIM: CHL) wish to provide an update on Churchill's and its wholly owned subsidiary Planet Mining Pty Ltd's ("Planet") international arbitration cases against the Republic of Indonesia ("Indonesia") at the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes ("ICSID") in Washington DC. The arbitration relates to the revocation of the mining licenses that made up the East Kutai Coal Project in East Kalimantan ("EKCP"), Indonesia, in which Churchill/Planet held a 75% interest.

ICSID Document Inspection & Contemporaneous Police Raid on Jakarta Office

In accordance with the ICSID Tribunal's ("Tribunal") Procedural Order No 10, representatives from Churchill and the Republic of Indonesia met in Singapore on 29 August 2014 to inspect a designated bundle of original documents relating to the mining licenses. Whilst this Tribunal-ordered document inspection was in progress in Singapore, police officers from Indonesia raided the Company's Jakarta office and seized a number of documents, computers and back up drives supposedly as part of a new police investigation into alleged license document forgery.

It is the Company's view that this police raid was strategically timed to harm and prejudice the Company's case currently being heard by the Tribunal. The Company has accordingly made an application for provisional measures pursuant to Article 47 of the ICSID Convention and Rule 39 of the ICSID Arbitration Rules that the Tribunal recommend that Indonesia (i) return forthwith all documents and other items that were seized by the Indonesian police in the raid on 29 August 2014, and (ii) refrain from engaging in any conduct that would aggravate the dispute, alter the status quo or jeopardise the procedural integrity of the ICSID proceedings.

With regard to Indonesia's resurfaced allegations of document forgery, the Company categorically denies that it ever participated in or that it was ever in any way involved in the forgery of any documents. Furthermore, prior to the revocation of the EKCP mining licenses in which the Company held an interest, agencies of Indonesia regularly (i) visited the EKCP site, (ii) sought and received payments in relation to the EKCP properties, and (iii) were provided with exploration and other technical reports relating to the EKCP properties. The Company also notes that previous investigations, carried out by both the Indonesian police and the Independent Stage Agency (BAWASDA), into these allegations of document forgery concerning the Ridlatama EKCP mining licenses concluded there was no case to answer.

 

 

 

Intimidation of Churchill's Arbitration Witnesses & Jakarta Office Staff

Churchill wishes to advise that in addition to the raid on its Indonesian office, the Indonesian police have also recently issued summons that (i) identify certain Company personnel as suspects and (ii) require a number of the Company's current and former staff to attend formal interviews in the new police investigation into document forgery.

Consistent with the threats openly made by Indonesian counsel during the ICSID jurisdictional hearing in Singapore in May 2013, Indonesia is now targeting the Company's Indonesian employees (both current and former) presumably to harm and prejudice the ICSID arbitration proceedings. The Company has accordingly incorporated into the above referenced application for provisional measures that the Tribunal also recommend that Indonesia (i) refrain from threatening or commencing any criminal investigation or prosecution against the Company, their witnesses or employees pending the outcome of this arbitration, and (ii) stay or suspend any current criminal investigation or prosecution against the Company or the Company's personnel.

The Company has also requested advice as to whether the action of Indonesia targeting the Company's Indonesian personnel in itself constitutes a breach of the Bilateral Investment Treaties between Indonesia and the United Kingdom and Indonesia and Australia.

Indonesia's Request For Stand Alone Hearing On Forgery Allegations

On 15 September 2014 the Company received notification from its solicitors, Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP ("Quinn Emanuel") that Indonesia had written to the Tribunal requesting that a stand-alone hearing on its forgery allegations be conducted within 30 days. The Tribunal subsequently requested the Company's comments on Indonesia's request by 26 September 2014. Quinn Emanuel duly submitted the Company's response on 26 September 2014.

It is the Company's view Indonesia has lodged this application in a calculated attempt to derail the procedural timetable in the arbitration proceedings as is absurd for Indonesia to claim, as it has, that its application could be ruled on while preserving the current procedural schedule, under which Indonesia is due to file its full Counter Memorial on the merits on 12 November 2014 (i.e., in approximately six weeks).

The Company has accordingly filed submissions with the Tribunal strongly objecting to any alteration to the established schedule.

Indonesia's "Application" For Dismissal of Churchill's Claims

On 26 September 2014 the Company received notification from its solicitors that Indonesia had written to the Tribunal on 25 September 2014. Further to its submission of 15 September 2014, Indonesia submitted a so-called "Application for the Dismissal of Churchill and Planet's Claims".

This unusual "last minute" application by Indonesia has also requested an order by the Tribunal to modify the procedural timetable to schedule an immediate hearing within the next 30 days or sooner if feasible to resolve the forgery allegations as a discrete issue. Again the Company sees this application as part of a calculated strategic attempt to derail the arbitration proceedings a whole and notes that Indonesia has had 18 months to consider the Company's case on merits which include Indonesia's theory of alleged license forgery.

Whilst Indonesia's disjointed application raises a number of issues including allegations of forgery, background and actions of the Ministry of Forestry that seemingly contributed to the revocation of the EKCP mining licenses, as well as the economics and feasibility of the EKCP and the damages value that has been claimed by Churchill/Planet, it does not address many of the substantive issues raised in the Company's Memorials and claim for damages.

Accordingly, the Company through its lawyers, Quinn Emanuel, has requested the Tribunal reject any attempt by Indonesia to litigate piecemeal the merits of the case and to direct Indonesia to complete its submissions on the merits by 12 November 2014 as set out in the established procedural schedule.

The Company will make further announcements when the Tribunal's decisions on its application for provisional measures and Indonesia's application for dismissal of Churchill's claims are delivered.

END

For further information, please contact:

Churchill Mining plc

David Quinlivan

Nicholas Smith

Russell Hardwick

+ 61 8 6382 3737

Northland Capital

Partners Limited

Edward Hutton/William Vandyk

+44(0)20 7382 1100

 

 

 

This information is provided by RNS
The company news service from the London Stock Exchange
 
END
 
 
MSCWGUPABUPCUMU
Date   Source Headline
23rd Jun 20088:49 amRNSProject update
17th Jun 20082:52 pmRNSSpitfire Resources Ltd - Dire
27th May 20087:00 amRNSProject Update
23rd May 20087:00 amRNSSpitfire Resources Update
12th May 20089:58 amRNSExercise of Warrants
1st May 20087:00 amRNSSpitfire Quarterly Report
30th Apr 20088:28 amRNSTotal Voting Rights
24th Apr 20086:24 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company
21st Apr 20082:19 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company
17th Apr 200811:53 amRNSExercise of Options
15th Apr 200812:11 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company
14th Apr 20087:00 amRNSResource Update
8th Apr 20084:19 pmRNSExercise of Options
3rd Apr 200810:23 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
2nd Apr 20087:00 amRNSNew tenements acquired
27th Mar 20087:00 amRNSInterim Results
25th Mar 20081:30 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company
25th Mar 20081:30 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company
17th Mar 20087:00 amRNSTinfos invests in Spitfire
10th Mar 20089:37 amRNSExercise of Options
7th Mar 200812:29 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company
7th Mar 20087:00 amRNSScoping Study
29th Feb 20088:43 amRNSBoard Change
28th Feb 20089:44 amRNSSpitfire Resources Update
30th Jan 20087:28 amRNSProject Update
29th Jan 20088:32 amRNSSpitfire Quarterly Report
10th Jan 200811:44 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
4th Jan 20089:07 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
20th Dec 200710:42 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
18th Dec 20078:29 amRNSVoting rights and capital
18th Dec 20078:21 amRNSExercise of options
14th Dec 200711:27 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
14th Dec 200711:24 amRNSResult of AGM
14th Dec 200710:47 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
11th Dec 200711:01 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
10th Dec 20077:00 amRNSDisposal
21st Nov 200712:04 pmRNSIssue of Equity
20th Nov 20077:02 amRNSFinal Results
9th Nov 20078:46 amRNSIssue of Equity
8th Nov 20079:01 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
22nd Oct 20077:00 amRNSIssue of Equity
17th Oct 20077:01 amRNSDrilling Report
4th Oct 20077:01 amRNSDisposal
3rd Oct 20077:01 amRNSDirectorate Change
5th Sep 20073:36 pmRNSNew License
7th Aug 20078:23 amRNSWebsite information
3rd Aug 200710:25 amRNSExercise of options
2nd Aug 20078:17 amRNSHolding(s) in Company
25th Jul 20078:20 amRNSEast Kutai update
19th Jun 20071:12 pmRNSHolding(s) in Company

Due to London Stock Exchange licensing terms, we stipulate that you must be a private investor. We apologise for the inconvenience.

To access our Live RNS you must confirm you are a private investor by using the button below.