JayKay24 Mar 2019 23:17
Could it be that you maybe misunderstanding FPTP ? I have lived in a PR state and it sounds fair on paper, but it is not. The governments of PR can usually only survive by going into coalition with other parties. and they are paid of by giving them government departments to manage. So a British model could see Labour running defence, Conservatives the Home office, LibDems the NHS etc etc etc. None of them dare slam the door when they are visiting/leaving another Department. In effect PR stifles democracy because people who perhaps voted with something in mind find although their party received more votes than any other party, that still amounts of only 25% of the vote. it cannot govern on 25% so they make up the missing 26% from other their parties. The other parties don't come cheap they want their pet projects. It often takes weeks or months (ask Holland) before one of the parties can win over (usually with political bribes) enough smaller parties to form a government and the larger party, the one that got 25% has to shelve a lot of the principles they espoused during the election, likewise their alliance parties do not get everything they want either, but they are in the stronger position because the can withdraw, causing a collapse of the majority 25%, who are now left scrabbling around the communists and daydream parties to fill the void and keep them in power but, of course, that give the communists and daydream parties powers above what their electoral status is . So I repeat what I said before, PR is very poor government, it is not at all democratic and it is often paralysised because it cannot bring the parties it is allayed with on side