RE: CHROME HERNIC/INYONI19 Nov 2019 16:43
Hi BB2, I have taken some time today to update my JLP numbers and read carefully your numbers. Firstly, you are quite correct in the number of "grey" areas between the summarised numbers and the actual end of year numbers both in terms of £'s and Oz's. Equally if you add up the earnings from the Oz's/T invoiced the revenues match but JLP seems to have found a few extra million in earnings above and beyond the £5m extra found in the impairments - good business if you can get it !!
I have done my summary in the same order as yours for simplicity.
PGM - Inyoni - our numbers are very similar, I have taken a slightly more pessimistic view on the PGM Oz's which also gives me a bit of slack on the PGM price - my numbers are Rev:£16.5m, Earnings £8.6m.
PGM - Windsor - my earnings numbers are quite different to yours. I believe JLP will hit close to the 60,000 Oz per year and that all of that revenue will come into JLP's P&L. In terms of earnings I am less optimistic that you in that we only know that JLP get the Lion's share so I have assumed 51% - my numbers are Rev: £33m, Earnings 9.5m. the important one -Earnings is at the top end of your range.
Chrome - Windsor - we are very similar here - my numbers are Rev: £13.7m, Earnings 3.0m.
Chrome DCM - Again similar - my numbers are Rev: £3.8m, Earnings 400k. (Hardly worth bothering about if it wasn't for the PGM material that we get).
Chrome Hernic - I have used a slightly lower Cr Conc Tonnage but I certainly hope and perhaps expect that you may be accurate. However my costs are higher, I read the £2/tonne costs as feed material rather than Cr Conc produced - my numbers are Rev 4.6m, Earnings 3.09m.
And then we have Kabwe !! Well a slow ramp up really from 2020 but the Cu revenue could be quite high since all of that will go to the P&L, it then depends upon how JLP allocate costs and earnings across the base metals since many of the costs are shared. My numbers are Rev £9.8m and Earnings of £1.5m. It's a bit of a guess but at least a starting point.
All of that totals Rev: £81.5m and Earnings of £26.1m so we are really very close and also similar to AW2414 numbers.
JLP have stated they will pull forward the fine Chrome at Hernic so we may see that come on line in the first 6 months of next year although I don't think we will see too much hit the P&L.
I have not yet checked my actual P&L numbers until I have gone through this years with a little more detail to give my EPS numbers and then it's just a case of what multiplier the MM's want to use.
Hope that helps and please all any input is much valued as well as pointing out any mistakes.