RE: Basel faulty 327 Feb 2021 09:13
Having implemented Basel 1 and 2, as well as managed the daily transfer and monitoring of the T1 account for a global bank. I can't see that many will hold gold, a) its costly to store. b) most bank use their T1 asset pool. For example the bank I worked for, would use the 8bn or so during the day, then at 4pm UK time it would transfer the money to cover the T1 back to the ECB account, then use it again the next day. A bending of the rules, but within them, as the money covering The T1 was measured at midnight each day. During the day it would be used to cover all kinds of positions, mostly to other banks, who would have to pay it back by 3pm.
If you think about it, a bank like Deutsche Bank, would make payments for hundreds of banks around the world each day. most of the banks would have open positions with DEUT which would need to be settled through EBA, SWIFT, Target etc. why not use your T1 money, that you have to put aside to do this, during the day? Which is in fact what all the large banks do. I know this is what BARC, DEUT, JPMO, HSBC, CITI do. You can't if its gold.
It makes a mockery of the entire requirement, but was within the rules. If you've got Gold, you can't do this. You can't collateralise against it. You can't do jack. Also if gold went down in value, you would have to keep topping it up with other Tier 1 category instruments, banks wouldn't want this level of uncertainty.