RE: The Times tonight1 Jul 2025 07:13
ALISTAIR OSBORNE | BUSINESS COMMENTARY
Can the FCA see Wood for the trees?
new
The Financial Conduct Authority looks spoilt for choice in its investigation into John Wood Group, the consulting engineer
Alistair Osborne
, Chief Business Commentator
Monday June 30 2025, 10.00pm BST, The Times
Maybe some companies try to get investigated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Take consulting engineer John Wood Group, the self-styled home of “Remarkable people, trusted by clients to design, build and advance the world”.
One of its remarkable feats was to issue a come-and-get-me statement on March 31, relating to an independent review by Deloitte. There, the board chaired by the £304,450-a-year Roy Franklin, admitted to, among other things: “material weaknesses and failures in the group’s financial culture within the projects business unit”; “inappropriate management pressure and override to maintain previously reported positions”; “over-optimism and/or lack of evidence in respect of accounting judgments”; and “instances of information being inappropriately withheld from, and unreliable information being provided to, Wood’s auditors” — KPMG.
Even the FCA couldn’t miss that sort of open goal. So it proved on Friday, with the news it had begun an investigation for “the period from 1 January 2023 to 7 November 2024” — the date when Wood said it had commissioned Deloitte’s review.
• Chairman of troubled John Wood Group to stand down
The regulator looks spoilt for choice, too. Its inquiry spans a period during which, apart from the accounting shenanigans and cultural issues, the board has lost two proposed cash bids at the point of due diligence: first, a £1.66 billion tilt from Apollo at 240p a share and then one from Sidara at 230p. And all before finding itself in takeover talks once again with Sidara — only now at the apparently “attractive” price of 35p a share, valuing Wood at just £242 million.
The reason for the gulf in the price? Because, in between, the board crashed the shares — before getting them suspended at 18.44p after failing to publish Wood’s 2024 accounts. To the lost bids, the board added missed financial targets, the joys of hiring a finance chief, Arvind Balan, who over-inflated his qualifications, project write-offs and the findings of the Deloitte review.
True, the latest update in February still showed a $6.2 billion order book and Wood continues to win business, notably a $2.8 billion contract from Abu Dhabi National Oil Company. But Wood’s £2.24 million-a-year chief executive Ken Gilmartin keeps missing his target for positive free cashflow (delayed until 2026). And, with net debt averaging $1.1 billion, the choice looks to be Sidara’s possible bid (whose deadline’s been extended again) or a debt-for-equity swap.
So, a question for the FCA: who will it blame for a mess that’s swiftly destroyed £1.4 billion of value? It’s the board’s job to set the company