RE: Valuation of ITH and HBR3 Aug 2025 21:44
I intended to post this earlier, but work kept me busy. Would have seemed cleverer dated Thursday 31st July with brent at 83:
Good Question!
To begin with, I believe they are both undervalued (as many energy stocks). I am currently not invested in HBR, whereas ITH is by far my biggest portfolio position.
Both companies chose to deal with the disastrous UK O&G related fiscal development completely differently. Whereas HBR chose to diversify, ITH has taken a path of regional consolidation. For now ITH was more “successful” if you compare pure sp performance. Morally, the path Linda has chosen (to prepare for a potential good bye), can be perceived as the correct reaction to the political nonsense everybody is facing…
Financial comparison (ITH vs. HBR):
- Number of shares quite similar (doesn´t matter per se, info just provided to calc div. per share) with 1,69b vs. 1,53b
- Dividend 500 mUSD vs. 455 mUSD, dividend per share 0,29 USD vs. 0,29 USD (does not include for non-equal divi distr)
- EVs 7,3b GBP vs. 3,4 GBP
Share price developments will (beside oil & gas prices) depend on UK fiscal decisions to be made between now and early November (Autumn budget). ITH should benefit stronger from positive decisions, since they are a UK north sea pure play with high direct production exposure and additional development potential (i.e. Cambo).
Thanks to the global diversification strategy, HBR has developed from a quite similar operating model (UK pure play) to a much more diversified global active player. With development opportunity in Mexica/Argentina (some people could argue the UK has proven worse…). In a worst case scenario (Labor does not move a bit, which is highly unlikely in my personal opinion given all the consultations during H1-25) HBR could end up selling their UK exposure (to Ithaca and Enquest for example), ending up a non-UK play in the end.
From a macro perspective, people I trust and follow see oil prices potentially under pressure for another 3-4 quarters. Inventory builds to start from Q4 after cooling season subsides. Next oil bull run to begin latest end of 2025, when the broad market realizes that there is no further growth to be expected from US shale, but global oil demand will continue to grow. In the meanwhile oil supposed to be rangebound between 60 and 70 USD/boe (could start falling soon, if Trump does not get serious with secondary sanctions on buyers of Russian oil)
My personal investment strategy looks like:
- I´ve sold HBR as a “hedge” against falling oil prices from now (brent at 73 USD/boe)
- Would start adding HBR from 1,80 GBP (maybe if brent gets down to 60ish)
- ITH IPOd with 11% dividend yield, which implies 2,00 GBP per share, so at close to 1,80 GBP we are approaching an okay level and had some run since 1,00-1,10 GBP absolutely overseld levels.
PS: Londoner, I intended to work myself through the NSTA numbers this weekend but didn´t find the time. Do you have anything to