FRUS-trated5 Oct 2018 09:31
My take on a stock buyback and what it really means :
There are 3 things the company can do when it buys back stock - and none of them are in anyway dilutionary, lets be clear about that...
It can buy the stock back and cancel them...eg if you think of each equity certificate as an IOU, it buys back 10% of the equity and cancels it...then the company has 90% of the stock it had before hand...good for EPS as you are dividing earnings by a smaller number of shares...and the preferred way of huge US multi-nationals who make gazillions of $$ and have no other way of boosting their EPS...
It can buy the stock back and hold them in treasury - to resell at a higher price to avoid exactly the dilution you worry about...so lets say it buys 10% of the stock of the company back at an average of 35p over the next 3 months (nice idea, huh)...it holds them in a treasury account and in 6 months time SLE says, for example, we want to buy a stake in XYZ oil field...and we are going to sell those shares we bought at 35p 6 months ago at the new exciting 50p share price to a new investor who likes our strategy, thereby absolutely preventing any dilution of which you are so concerned.
Or option 3. it can hold those shares and use them to reward those it feels have done the company a great service without drawing down on valuable cash...again no dilution by issuing of new shares, just a gift per se to the FD, or the CEO, or whoever...at the company's discretion...might be a bit of grumbling in the cheap seats, but they are the board and you have by investing in them given them the right to run the company as they see fit...
All 3 of these options have merits...all depend slightly on the company basically saying we have no better use for the cash that we are building up in our coffers (through these quarterly repayments) but none of them will impact your shareholding should you not care to sell your stock...which is absolutely up to you...which leads me to point 4...a point I have tried to make a few times...
If the company gets permission to buy $10mm of the stock back...and 75% of the outstanding stock is in the hands of either Tosca, MWP or the board who i think we must believe are in this for the long game, then who is going to sell them the stock...at 28p? Ergo, the share price will have to rise to a level, whatever that be, where you, or me, or S8, or BlueRill, or Blackswan or whoever decides right, I am happy to sell...now that might be 30p, it might be higher...but you have to make your own decision when you want to sell your stock complete in the understanding that a stock buyback is NOT a bad thing!