RE: Latest thoughts20 Jan 2020 19:54
Of course, I agree that we don't want young kids stumbling across porn, but the government's responsibility is secondary - It is the parent's responsibility. The government should just be providing the information to help the parents do their job.
There are tools on all devices to prevent the content being shown - better than any age verification tool (but certainly not perfect) and you can even ask your ISP to block it at that level. If you have young children in your home then just take a small amount of your time to go and learn how to block this content from them. The majority of homes do not have children in them and they certainly don't have young children, so why force all adults to go through this process?
When children become teenagers they will search out the content. Only the big sites, which show legal content, will use the age verification and it will ultimately lead to teenagers:
1) Viewing content on other sites that are not legally required to get verification
2) Teaching an entire generation about VPN's and why every household should have one - which the government definitely doesn't want
3) Worst of all, they search and go down the rabbit hole of dodgy sites until they get viruses, illegal content and who knows what other possibilities, grooming, blackmail, etc.
I also think that the age verification tools will very quickly be cracked or credentials shared should a great demand appear for that and, if you're not logging access, then how can you stop them? If you are logging them, then you're a data risk.
I also fear for how far they might let it go. The two most annoying/frustrating parts of the internet are the sheer number of ads that are shown, severely degrading performance/the experience and pop-ups that get in the way. Yet, the EU government basically enforced every single website in the EU to have a pop-up telling you about cookies when you visit it!! People that don't understand the internet shouldn't be making decisions on it.
Imagine browsing the internet and having to authenticate again and again through different age verification providers as you browse your favourite "discovery" site, like facebook, reddit or even the likes of the bbc. Any video that's 18+ being required to verify your age. It's already there on some video sites... you won't believe the number of people that were born on January 1st 19XX! :)
I think that there is a place for age verification and twitter/Facebook are good examples. However, I believe that enforcing it on porn sites will lead to greater problems. A better solution is for parents to learn to block at the household level and for schools to educate the children on this and the many other modern online issues.
I do wish you luck with your business SJL and my comments are not going to affect anything, I just think it was a bad idea from the start... and the government has treated your company badly because of the initial decision.
That's all I have to say on this