RE: 40p17 Jan 2020 19:57
wisdom, you ask, 'Wonder how much AB has made on his purchases at 16 - 18p?'
That's easy, 72%.
But you made me wonder about his earlier purchases and the impact of capital restructures.
In 31/5/11 he purchased 922K shares @ 131.95p for circa £1.2m. Based on a quick look that seems to have been the highest price he paid but he made other substantial purchases in 2011 at around 100p per share.
But there are other detrimental considerations - Rights and placings - which have diluted those holdings. There were placings in Oct 16 and the recent Rights Issue in Sept 18.
One way of assessing the dilution is to consider the number of shares in issue in May 2011 (802M) and the number in issue today (1,695M), representing a dilution of >100%. The relative market caps are May 2011 (£1,058M) and today (£496M).
I don't think AB will be cracking open the champagne just yet!
Over the years there has been many trading opportunities in Enquest but IMO it has never been a good investment. As an investor rather than a trader I need to consider if it's different this time. Early in 2019 I felt it was and as my knowledge and confidence grew during the year so did my investment.
Early 2019 I saw a company under the cosh from many quarters, Cairn, Barclays and RBS to name a few - those broker summaries can still be viewed on Investors Chronicle, which basically pointed to Enquest falling the wrong side of hitting the RCF repayment schedule based on anticipated Cap Ex and Oil prices. In the event, oil prices were slightly higher, Cap Ex appears to be lower (to be confirmed next month) and the RCF payments were made ahead of schedule. It appears that the brokers recognise that outcome and the recent CMD suggests a plan for fast payback and good returns on organic investments over the next few years with upgrades to price targets - that said, I'm more interested in the detail of their assessments than (IMO) a meaningless price target - does 40p make ENQ a sell?
To date Enquest management hasn't been up to the task of developing assets, A/G being one example and let's be frank Kraken may be throwing off cash now but a decent return on the original investment is questionable. I think the Magnus transaction has marked the turning point and in spite of the odd operations challenge may be the feather in management's cap – in particular the repayment structure. Risks abound with aging infrastructure but I see a greater risk with an overpriced NS acquisition. Magnus was timely, and credit to AB, brave, but the recent PMO acquisition isn't as attractive and probably represents the higher price now being asked for the oil majors North Sea cast-offs. I think the upcoming licence awards may represent a better path to growth.
Today I see a better investment case for Enquest at 30p than I did at 20p last May. I'm sticking but expecting a roller coaster (and an occasional scream).
This morning I noted the penny traders coming 4 weeks late to the party -