IC: Strong Buy at 168p....20 Feb 2017 13:50
Simon Thomson 31.10.16 .."Shares in Aim-traded aircraft leasing company Avation (AVAP:168p) took off at the end of last week after the board received an unsolicited approach to buy its wholly owned portfolio of ATR72 turboprop aircraft. The company owns 24 of these ATR72 planes, of which two are subject to finance leases, and the expression of interest relates to the 22 planes owned outright, which are funded by debt facilities. .....
According to analyst John Cummins at house broker WH Ireland, the current fleet value of these ATR72 planes is $385m (£315m) post depreciation based on an original acquisition cost of $440m. He notes that "assuming the debt against these aircraft is paid back over a 25-year period, and on average just under 80 per cent of the purchase price is funded through debt, this would imply a conservative net asset value (NAV) for these 22 aircraft of around $85m, or 118p a share." This means that the 16 other planes in Avation's portfolio - five Fokker 100s, nine Airbus A321s and A320s, and the two ATR72s subject to finance leases - have a net asset value of $88.6m, or 124p a share.
That's worth noting because executive chairman Jeff Chatfield says that any sale will have to be priced at a premium to book value, and understandably so. Rival Avolon was acquired at close to 1.6 times book value earlier this year by Bohai Leasing, a Chinese public company listed on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange. Subsequent to that deal completing, Avolon has since purchased a portfolio of aircraft at a 20 per cent premium to book value. The point being that, with Avation's shares trading 30 per cent below book value, there is obvious potential for significant shareholder value to be created through the sale of the company's ATR72 portfolio at a premium to book value, and then recycling this capital into new aircraft purchases.
True, there is no guarantee a deal will be done, but with Avation's shares priced on only six times likely EPS of 27.5p in the 12 months to the end of June 2017, offering a 1.8 per cent prospective dividend yield and rated well below book value, investment upside from any disposal is in the price for free.
So, having recommended buying Avation's shares at 147p at the time of the full-year results ('In the ascent', 12 Sep 2016), I feel that my fair value estimate of 220p is looking conservative and I have raised it to a target range between 225p and 240p. At the upper end the shares would be rated on less than nine times earnings, and 10 per cent below the end of June 2017 NAV estimates of 266p a share, excluding any bid premium on a sale of the ATR portfolio. Strong buy"