RE: V and A and valuation14 Jul 2024 08:26
Bold,
You are correct that chariots renewables are valued at nil by the market.
Part of that problem is that shareholders have little to no financial information regarding the performance of that division.
The reason is that the investments are made via special purpose vehicle entities in which chariot hold minority interests in such companies which also have high levels of project debt in each spv investment. So until the spv debt is repaid, no spv dividends can be paid to the investors in the spv and hence no indication of the performance of such investments.
However, as the debt is being repaid in each spv, real value is being generated but shareholders cannot see this.
Chariot is accounting for its renewable investments in accordance with accounting rules.
However, chariot can include additional voluntary information regarding the performance of its renewables in its accounts. For example it could report the amount of project debt in each project, it’s % equity ownership of each spv and the change in debt in each spv, this would provide a rough estimate of the cash generation of each spv and allow shareholders to estimate how long each project will take to pay a dividend to its equity investor. Hence value creation is more obvious.
Just a thought, perhaps others might have other ideas.
Obviously , a third party equity investor in the renewable holding company would also provide another basis for valuation and potentially release cash to the chariot.
Jimmy