RE: Very quiet on here1 Feb 2025 06:07
Money tree idea.
HSBC Premier account requires you to keep £50k with them.
"For either an InvestDirect or an InvestDirect Plus account, you'll pay a quarterly account fee of £10.50." So, £42 a year.
The S&S ISA is free.
No custodian fee for keeping shares in it.
No charge for collecting dividend.
If you bought 10,000 shares HSBA at £5, for £50k, you can just leave it there,
generating dividend tax free inside the ISA.
https://www.hl.co.uk/shares/shares-search-results/h/hsbc-holdings-plc-ordinary-usd0.50/dividends
USD$0.61 ~ GBP0.49 which is back to normal pre-COVID.
10,000 shares generates £4,900 a year.
After deducting £42 annual fee, you are left with £4,858 a year, tax free.
The problem with ISA is, you can't bear to withdraw cash, and lose the tax free status.
So you just re-invest the dividends, diversifying if you want to.
Twenty years later, it's easy to end up with £200k.
Now it's £200k in an ISA, but are you really going to take it out, and lose the tax free status?
If you have cash outside, earning taxable interest, in shares earning taxable dividend,
incurring taxable capital gains when you sell, are you really going to take the £200k out?
The cash outside is queueing to go in, so you will spend that first.
If you wait, the ISA soon reaches £300k.
The bigger it is, the faster it grows.
What we really need is an equity release loan, with a lien on the ISA.
You spend the money now, and the lender gets the ISA money when you die.
Until you die, the ISA keeps making money tax free.
Ideally, around three years ago, HSBC lends me £1m at 2%, secured on my ISA and other assets. Fixed for ten years, or more.
The loan will reduce my estate, drastically reducing inheritance tax.
All too good to be true, sadly.
Even more tragic, I don't think I will ever withdraw cash from my S&S ISA.