RE: US$ starts to breakdown and then what ...22 Jul 2020 14:11
Indeed, given the impossibility of selling forward a “future” Italian lira that no longer existed, countries like Italy, Spain and even France broadly became no-go zones for long-term capital, thereby widening differences in productivity. As Ionesco once said “caress a circle and it becomes vicious”. The question today is whether Europe’s plan to deliver the fiscal backbone it lacks changes the above equation. If nothing else, this change should mean that the euro stops being the red-haired step child of foreign exchange markets, and again becomes a credible alternative to the US dollar for global foreign exchange reserve managers and asset allocators. This isn’t to say that the euro is set to come roaring back—Europe has many other issues to fix—but at the very least, the euro is no longer on one long downhill ride.
3) Asia is not monetizing the Covid crisis like the US is doing. A divergence in policy responses to the Covid-19 hit between the “East” (centered on China) and the “West” (US and Europe) reminds of responses to the 1970s oil price shock. Back then, the US, UK and France monetized the surge in the oil price that followed the 1973 Arab oil embargo. For their part, Germany, Switzerland and Japan chose to take the price hike on the chin, despite facing short-term economic pain. The result was a decade-long depreciation of the US dollar, pound sterling and French franc against the yen, deutschmark and Swiss franc. Today, we are seeing the same divergence, with China leading the “anti-monetization” pack, while the US leads the way in money creation (see table below and Toward A Renminbi-Gold Standard). Incidentally, this different monetary approach may partly explain the recent divergence between Chinese bond yields creeping higher and US yields flatlining at low levels. Such a divergence in long term interest rates argues for further US dollar weakness.
4) US uncertainties. Another explanation for the dollar’s apparent breakdown is recent news out of the US having been fairly dismal. Between riots, an inability to tackle the Covid-19 pandemic, the impression of divided government (the White House against governors and Congress; governors against mayors), daily headlines have not been pretty. In addition, there is growing political uncertainty linked to the electoral calendar (will foreigners stay overweight US assets if the Democratic Party sweeps the upcoming elections and unleashes a program of higher corporate income taxes, higher capital gain taxes, and perhaps even the introduction of wealth taxes?). And given record-high unemployment, it is hard to see who will be the marginal buyer of US dollars. Sure, the US remains the world’s global tech leader, but it increasingly looks as if the tech world could break apart into different zones (US, China, India, Europe) each with its rules, regulations and national champions. If this duly unfolds, big US tech companies now priced to keep dominating the world as they did in the past de