RE: Anuver bade daye agane sadley19 Mar 2024 18:23
In Vodafone's case I believe share buybacks are probably the way to go, whereas I took a different view in the case of Lloyds with over twice the issued shares in circulation. I suppose the easiest way to decide whether or not buybacks are worthwhile, would be to determine how much they'll save in annual dividend payouts vs how much they could earn in interest by banking the €4 Billion.
Vodafone has 28,818,683,808 ordinary shares of which 1,739,701,451 ordinary shares are held in Treasury.
Dividend bill before buybacks would be:
(28,818,683,808 - 1,739,701,451) x 4.5 Eurocent = €1,218,554,206
Dividend bill after buybacks at 70p (€0.82) per share:
€4 Billion-0.5% =€3.98 Billion (stamp duty)
€3.98 Billion/0.82= 4,853,658,536 shares purchased
(27,078,982,357 - 4,853,658,536) = 22,225,323,821 shares in circulation after buyback
22,225,323,821 x 4.5 Eurocent = €1,000,139,571 annual dividend payout
Difference in dividend payment after buyback:
€1,218,554,206 - €1,000,139,571 = €218,414,635 (17.92% annual saving)
If they banked the €4 Billion, much would depend on the interest rate they could negotiate. I have no idea how much interest corporates can earn for loaning out their cash, but I'd guess it isn't without some risk. If they negotiated a return of 6% it would pull in around €240,000,000 a year in interest, which would probably be accounted for against how much they are paying out in interest on their debt and is more than they save in dividends from the buybacks.
Interest received and paid feeds directly into the Free Cashflow calculation, whereas dividend payments are deducted afterward and feeds directly into Net Debt. If Vodafone's share price goes up they'll get less shares from the buybacks, and I've also guessed the interest rate they might get if they banked the cash, and there may be very good reasons why they're better off with buybacks, so take everything I've typed with a pinch of salt.
I'll happily be corrected if I've misunderstood something, or got something wrong.