RE: Thungela: The dirty secret delivering a 1,600% return for Abrdn, Odey and Schroders21 Sep 2022 17:00
Pt 2
Topping that, asset manager Abrdn is the sixth largest shareholder in Thungela, according to Refinitiv data, with several of its funds holding the stock. These include: Abrdn Equity Income (AEI), where it is the third largest position in the £199m investment trust run by Thomas Moore; Moore’s open-ended Abrdn UK Income Unconstrained Equity fund, where it is the fourth largest position, making up 4.5% of the £578m portfolio at the end of July; the £108m Abrdn UK Growth Equity fund run by Andrew Millington; and Abrdn UK High Alpha Equity, the £81m fund that Millington runs with Guy Douthwaite.
Abrdn, Odey and Schroders all declined to comment.
While Thungela’s green credentials leave a lot to be desired – particularly for managers who are being forced to consider the ESG merits of their investments – the numbers continue to stack up as demand for coal outstrips supply.
In half-year results last month, the miner reported profits of more than 20 times the year before on the back of soaring coal prices.
Ben Davis, analyst at Liberum, Thungela’s corporate broker, said in August that the miner had delivered a ‘chunky beat’ to numbers and a ‘chunkier dividend’.
‘Management has stuck with its capital returns policy, that all cash after a buffer of 6bn rand post-base dividend is surplus and will be distributed to shareholders,’ said Davis.
‘The dividend of 60 rand per share has an implied annualised dividend yield of 43%. We expect an even larger dividend of 67 rand per share at the full-year results, assuming there is no [merger and acquisition].’
The only issue Thungela has had in its meteoric rise has been a restriction on the amount of coal it can ship out of South Africa due to logistics problems. While Thungela had sold all its coal to Anglo American while under its umbrella, the demerger has seen it diversify its customer base, selling into Europe.
Earlier this year Thungela chief executive July Ndlovu said the group had been plagued by logistics issues caused by South Africa’s state-owned rail and port company Transnet, which has had freight operations hobbled by large-scale copper theft. He said at the time that it was a ‘missed opportunity’ for the company, the mining industry and South Africa.
Anglo’s coal divestment leaves Glencore as the last major holdout in coal among global miners. The Swiss group reported record $19bn profits in the first half of year, with its coal divison generating half of that and more money than the entire group at the same time last year.