RE: Renegotiation with BP24 Sep 2020 19:51
PMO1 are an indicate to the extent they are the only elements of the cap table, outside other ordinary shares, that we can see a market price for.
Yes, they have been as lower as 32% of par, my point was that being public they may provide insight into elemets of the cap table we can't see prices for. That all being said, the major disposal of part of the cap table by a signifiant entity at 72% (as being reported by Reteurs, and the possible lack of interest again as being reported by Reuters) is interesting when the publically traded debt is now below that 72% mark.
I agree with you, I expect them to go lower, but you have to consider this in the mix. Most buyers of retail bonds hold them with the intention of keeping them to maturity. They aren't speculating in them, so aren't watching them on a daily basis.
They will also be held my institutions and family office, who will be watching on a daily basis. They aren't exclusively retail products. So there's the potential for them to lag, but that doesn't mean they aren't indicative of wider sentiment.
I don't think it does undermine my arguement. My arguement isn't that company wont be around - or whatever Happy calls it - my arguement is that I don't know what the cap table is going to be like going forward and if there's was a creditors/stakeholders waterfall, there's little chance of anything for sharehoders with the level of debt. I suspect there will be pain coming down the line for both positions, equity and debt, but it's very unlikely not to be felt by shareholders more than any other party given equities position vis-a-vis debt. I'm not sure you can decribe a credit default as teetering on the edge for business, as much as teetering on the edge for shareholders. I've also said I'm sure there's a future for the company, just less sure who the owners will be. THERE is a difference. In some terms shareholders are seen as owners of the business, in other accounting terms it's seen a who has greatest claims on the future earning of a business, and at this point it feels like creditors do. I think that a fair position given the uncertainty, PMO1 might be up of it's lows, but that doesn't mean it wont see them again.