RE: Chat on this page20 Sep 2021 19:28
Tedmark
I dont recall anybody, certainly not myself, saying that the fundamentals are poor here? or that any decline in the daily shareprice was terminal in any way.
The conversation was around the daily ups and downs and trading such occurances. And quite clearly that was the most sensible thing to do after the recent falls, making quite a reasonable % gain, allowing new entrants a cheaper price, or indeed the oppo to average down or rebuy back cheaper and increase a stake..
It got 'messy' simple because one ramper decided to critisise somebody for not just blindly holding on as he had done, almost as if any traders havent got the right to chose their own choices. Indeed 'traders' per se were also critisised.
Unbeleivable another who had done exactly the same 'trading' joined in defending the ramper, his math however was more than dubious and shown as incorrect.
Like you, am more than happy to read contrarian views, but they really need to have substance and evidence to back them up, and of course be factually correct when rubbishing others calculations, and neither childish in tone.
Of course what also should be paramount in ANY investor/traders mind is the chaining market situation. It is of course a fact that this changed this last few days with the SA sell off, the news on the chinese building giants troubles, Fed etc etc. Nothing is static, and it is a total fool who isnt able to revisit his view objectively given changes in the base information.
Just to be 101% clear, i personally view this business as investable, but after Fridays plunge took good profits, which is the main object. Whether those profits are reinvested, for trading or as a long term hold, will depend on all the information availible to me at the time i make my own choice.
Am pleased coal is up, and you added to your holding, cheaper of course, but the right move on the day was to sell.