Greenhaven Latest2 Mar 2025 14:05
Burford (BUR) - Burford isn't just "getting there" - they're already the leader in litigation finance with a 27% historical gross IRR and losses on only 13% of cases, according to their disclosures. I have gone out of my way in past letters to highlight just how good the company has been historically at financing litigation. They rarely lose money on cases, in part because the vast majority (76%) settle. They do, however, occasionally have "monster winners" that return 10X, 50X or even 100X their initial investment.
Burford's leadership team personally owns stock totaling 9% (>$200M) of the company and has been a net buyer of the shares. With aligned insider ownership, historically low loss rates, and tangible book value making up more than 80% of their share price, Burford is a well-capitalized and sustainable business.
In 2024, Burford was worse than "dead money" as it posted a share price decline. It is rarely easy to isolate the cause of a share price decline, but apparently investors had some consternation over the slowing pace of investments in new cases.
While I have tried to focus our attention on Burford's current and future business, I think it is time to look deeper at the YPF case.
The general facts of the YPF case are not disputed. YPF is an oil company operating in Argentina that was publicly traded In 2012, Argentina nationalized the company and gave no compensation to existing shareholders. Burford has been financing the case of the shareholders against Argentina. YPF still exists, and the Argentinian government has benefited for more than a decade from the shares they stole/nationalized without compensation.
This litigation against Argentina has gone on for years, including appeals by Argentina disputing if Burford even has the right to collect and if the U.S. courts have jurisdiction. The plaintiffs Burford financed were ultimately awarded $16B, which is earning $1B per year in interest. In round numbers, a full payout would likely be worth more than S6B for Burford, or $25+ per share. To put this in perspective, this is double where the shares ended the year for a single case in Burford's portfolio. We can debate the magnitude and timing of the ultimate payout, but I believe the expected value is not $O.