RE: Shorting8 Nov 2023 20:01
@confluence, it’s good to have your considered reply. So to your first point, surely the sp dropping heavily (and given this is not the first time at these levels) it is neither good or bad for you, unless you are a short term investor or day trading. It simply plays on your psychology but has little financial or tangible impact (unless you capitulate and sell your shares of course). So ‘reasonable people would agree is not a good thing’ is not applicable. Your next point is naive in regard to the sp dropping on no news and low volumes if you consider the shorters are generally experienced professional traders playing the markets (or acting on inside information, illegal, to which we can have little impact). I’m sure if we had the trading expertise we would be doing exactly the same thing. One advantage to active shorting is it gives PI the opportunity to buy in at very low prices, and I suspect you may have taken advantage of this in the past when it was in your favour but now feel aggrieved the sp is on the wrong side of your average. To your next point, how it plays out is not relevant to shorting either. So let’s say the sp is 80p , shorting is illegal and the company goes bust; compared to shorting the price down to 45p and the company goes bust. In both cases you have still lost the full value of your investment. But by your logic, you subconsciously like the shorting to alert you to the possibility of trouble and the option to sell at a loss but consciously find this manipulation abhorrent?