RE: Worth noting for 202512 Jan 2025 11:51
You are correct, Lemon, cherry picking won’t make money here. That said, some facts, including Ukrainian participation and views during WW1/WW2 are not that relevant.
The relevant fact of the war, and the reason we should help is that Ukraine didn’t ask to be invaded, didn’t ask Russia to commit war crimes on their territory, and their democratically elected leader asked for help. Security guarantees signed in 1994 gave the USA and UK an obligation to help (even had we not wanted to). So here we are. We owe Ukraine.
As for Ferrexpo there are two hugely relevant facts.
First is Russia has been unable to take and hold any substantial part of Ukrainian territory. What we thought was the second best army in the world is failing against a nation that is, well not exactly known for having top notch armed forces. The fact Russia can’t establish air supremacy is a sign they are simply not capable. Ferrexpo’s mine is a long way from the fighting and likely to remain so.
Second is that any deal will cement the status quo. Trump’s rhetoric is less relevant than the fact he is surrounding himself with Ukraine supporters at the top end of his administration. The deal will be to stop the fighting around current borders. The threats will be to Ukraine, we will cut off your weapons, and to Russia, we will carpet bomb Moscow and there is nothing you can do to stop us.
That is it. The investment case is clear as the base case is now a cessation of fighting and ceasefire around current borders. What is left of Ukraine gets back on its feet, with western help. Obviously other outcomes are possible, although now incredibly unlikely IMO.