Balanced view16 Jun 2019 14:34
Hopefully this is somewhat of a balanced view. We have 3 options here, either (a) court overrules, full steam ahead, (b) court back referendum and govt eventually deals with it, then full steam ahead, or (c) court backs referendum and cascabel is dead.
The government does not want to stop mining and are probably extremely worried that the majors will be put off investing in Ecuador. Some in power are probably worried about the loss of facilitation payments too...we have to accept the level of corruption that exists. Mining is massively important to them and the country. As a result they cannot allow a negative result to stand, but obviously they cannot stop the court offering a judgement before they can do anything. The constannt posts and articles suggest pressure is being applied to force the judge to 'do the right thing'. The fact they are doing this suggests they do not have confidence that the judge will. Their will to push this means this ending in no mining is extremely unlikely, but who can be 100% sure.
Given this, I'd say my gut feel is (a) judge rules against our illegal miner 40%, (b) judge rules for it, but govt eventually shut this down and mining is fine 59%, (c) referendum, mining stopped 1%. We all have our own percentages I'm sure.
For me this is a simple choice of accept it will be (a) or (b). If you are happy with either you hold and see immediate gain or buy more on the fall. It is then just a case of how long before you are hopefully making the profit you want. I am working on this basis, am holding and happy that I might see a painful hit in the short term. Longer term I expect all to be good as the government is not going to scare off the majors so will be working to resolve as quickly as possible once they have the chance. It will take time to build trust with the majors though, they will not like this at all.
All we should be really worried about is option c, which is extremely unlikely, but as ever nothing is impossible. Other than that, I see nothing else worth discussing until we get the result in a week or so.