RE: Was It Worth It?2 Jul 2020 19:37
PUTUP,
‘A Company can increase share count with the stroke of a pen. Issue 50m shares into treasury. Done. It doesn’t increase equity value.’
Of course it doesn’t. But these shares weren’t issued, they were bought on the open market at a range of prices over an extended period. And because they were purchased to satisfy the vesting of employee options they clearly have an immediate impact, reducing the net assets of GKP as demonstrated in the 2019 accounts.
‘5) And howsoever you calculate that loss, wherever you put it in the accounts, one way or another the net worth of GKP is reduced by that decision to cancel.’
Of course the decision to cancel, in and of itself, has no relevance to the Balance Sheet, that goes without saying. But ACTING on that resolution has a major effect and will create further equity write downs on top of those in the 2019 accounts if and when the Board act.
However, I agree with your assessment that further buybacks will follow, and according to the AGM Resolution these will be bought back into Treasury, as last time.
I contend when they’re bought back they should be cancelled, and they won’t be, as last time.
And what a wasted opportunity, as last time.