RE: HBR SHARE PRICE FELL 31.4% DESPITE RISING OIL PRICES12 Jun 2022 10:06
The discounted cash flow modelling illustrates the blindingly obvious. But if you look at Simple Wall Streets' analysis they have hugely understated the extent of the under valuation. First, they use a discount rate of 9.6% per annum. In other words a dollar received in June 2023 is worth 9.6% less than a dollar received today. That is far too high. For property valuations it is typically 4.75% per annum. If you use a very high discount rate then, with the effect of compounding, future earnings rapidly reduce in terms of present value. Second they are clearly off with their figures any way. The free cash flow for 2022 is stated as just $1.4 bn. It is going to be more than that - at least $1.7bn. The free cash flow (after discounting at 9.6%) for 2023 is estimated at just $944bn. It is going to be at least double that - and so on. And thirdly the calculations only cover a 10 year period. They are treating HBR as if it were a lease with 10 years to go before the property must be handed back to the landlord. Whereas in fact in 10 years HBR will still be around and the world will still need its products. On the often raised subject as to why seemingly rationale institutions are selling at these crazy low prices. I just do not know. But I am sure they do not have access to any information which we do not have access to. I think they are making a huge mistake which they will regret. August is coming and we will have a very clear picture by the next update. The losses made in just 6 weeks can be reversed in 8 weeks.