RE: Liberum Go long Centamin, short Endeavour8 Jan 2022 10:41
The case for selling Endeavour
As we noted in our initiation report (Ambitious, nimble West African gorilla is
currently fully valued, 15 December 2021), there is much to commend about
Endeavour. The company has an established track record at meeting
guidance, while committed minimum dividends and share buybacks make for
attractive indicative shareholder returns.
However, these all appear to be priced in: the market appears to be valuing
Endeavour - including upside potential - using a long-term gold price of
c.US$1,715/oz, or a low discount rate of c.5% (despite the difficult
geographies in which the company operates).
Meanwhile, Endeavour is currently relatively low-cost, but we will be watching
in 2022 to see just how well it is able to contain the inflationary pressures that
are being experienced in the mining industry globally. Margins could be
further pressured if the gold price trends down as we forecast.
In such a scenario, Endeavour’s committed minimum dividends could appear
increasingly attractive, particularly if the company maintains (or ups) the
tempo of share buybacks. However, a gold price downtrend could stymie
Endeavour’s hopes of joining the FTSE 100, particularly if the FTSE 100
trends up (Liberum’s strategy analysts are forecasting a 15-20% rise in that
index during 2022).
The short of it is that we see only a slim chance of FTSE 100 inclusion in the
near term, and our expectation is that this will offset the attractions of the
shareholder returns policy. Whilst there are a number of potential upside
catalysts during 2022 (e.g. DFS results for two key projects are to be released
in early 2022), these are relatively minor in the grand scheme of things. For
these reasons, we initiated with a HOLD rating.
Our Target Price for Endeavour of 1316p implies 15% downside, the
unattractiveness of which is magnified when set against the 22% upside to
our new Centamin target. We therefore downgrade Endeavour to SELL.