Nah. Seen this said many times. I was in BP last year and everyone saying dinosaur end of road sunset business. I just bought on massive undervalue wait 12 mths and double my money paid off mortgage
Same plan here buy when undervalued and bad sentiment then wait.
Forme this is always best strategy for big rtns as it works
You set the definitiom of what you classify as windfall or not then you say you other right and I'm am wrong based on a false truism that is only defined by you?
The world is full of events which are mostly not and certainly not in the example you give originated by shell but impact it. You are simply choosing which you badge as windfall or not. A definition of your own making so get over you own self importance of calling other wrong if you don't like their opinion.
Feel free to give your deplated "windfall" divi to charity of that's hpw you feel bit I will fight for mine
Totally agree with you it's what I've been saying. A windfall cannot be looked at on a specific narrow window of convenience...
1. The debt of the bad years is still on the balance sheet 2. The divi cut from the bad years is still with us 3. The huge bill of conversion to sustainable needs paying
...yet tech pay nothing, earn huge profits polute the earth with their data centres. That's where the windfall needs to be.
It makes me veryy angry this olly windfall talk. There is no windfall at all for anyone other than short term traders of the last year