RE: LSE is dead19 Sep 2025 20:55
I was so salty about AWE lol, acquired for $2.4 billion while the likes of Credo and Astera labs are currently $30-40 billion market cap. Thing is, recently it became clear that AWE likely wouldn't have survived, their 224G SerDes and UCIe is apparently worse than Synopsys and in that case they don't have much of an IP business. They also seemingly have no hope of competing with Broadcom in ASIC development and the Banias Labs oDSP business is going to be killed by co-packaged optics before it even gets started.
As you said Dartron, the current valuations of most of the US listed companies in this space are pretty rich, pretty much pricing in the next 5 years of growth for the likes of Broadcom and Nvidia. Interestingly, I was looking at Nvidia's financial statements and their revenue growth is surprisingly linear, adding ~$5 billion per quarter for the past 2 years resulting of an expectation of ~$54 billion for their Q3 2026. Naively extrapolating we get ~$200B FY26 revenue. Their net margin is something ridiculous like 75% (the past two quarters were 46% and 56% due to China writedowns). Putting all that together net profit should be about $130B for FY26 which is a 30x PE multiple at the current $4.2T market cap. Keeping the extrapolation going you get $220B FY27 profit, $280B FY28, ... adding $60 billion profit each year so $400B by FY30. Obviously there are questions about how much infrastructure is actually needed, losing access to China (33% of the market), competition from ASICs and so on. Not to mention this assumes insane 75% margins. As soon as the margin drops to 50% with the same assumption for revenue growth, FY30 profit drops 33% to ~$250B meaning 75% increase in share price (15% CAGR) with a 30 PE ratio.
All this to say you can make an argument that Nvidia's current valuation is pretty reasonable.
My portfolio is heavily geared towards WFE. Currently the only US company in my portfolio is Onto Innovation (I'm very confident on this one). I was also going to add Applied Materials but went for Tokyo Electron in the end due to greater NAND exposure and has been on an amazing run lately (Lam, KLA and ASML all at a bit of a premium for my taste and perhaps deservedly so). I'm also holding Soitec (with the idea of it eventually giving high exposure to silicon photonics) but that hasn't worked out too well for me yet and probably won't until closer to the 2028 Nvidia Feynman ramp, if ever lol.
I'm personally not a fan of the IDMs you mentioned, too commoditised for my taste and will probably suffer from oversupply and low margins for the foreseeable future due to Chinese players entering the market. Would be interested to hear your thoughts on this Dartron as I imagine your optimism is founded by your technical background.