RE: Ex-Head of investor relations (Phil Corbett)21 Jul 2022 03:01
Corbett might be a piece of s**t but at least he is gone. My main beef is with Chaffe. He should have started a programme of buying back bonds in the market during summer 2020 when they were down to something like 30% of par. Instead he sat on his hands and did nothing.
This is a quote from an email sent 18 September 2020 from Richard Bernstein to Steve McTeirnan included as an exhibit to Chaffe’s statement:
“As we conveyed, we expect to see a near immediate buyback of a significant quantity of the bonds. This morning, I checked the price:- 29-30! Tendering for 80% of the bonds at 35 would cost $64.4 million and leave the company with over $40 million of net cash. We urge the board to give an order to buy in stock at 30 on Monday- by the time you discuss it with your broker, the price will rally and cost the company more.”
They then got that letter from Adkin Gump on behalf of the bondholder consortium in September2020 telling them not to spend a penny without their say so. From then on they submitted to the demands of the consortium. On the 1st October Management presented the Board with an Executive Summary “POSSIBLE BUY BACK BY HURRICANE OF BONDS” which concluded with a recommendation against buying either in the market or tendering. The basis for making this recommendation was that they did not want to antagonise the bondholders.
In my opinion this was an incredible mistake. Had they embarked on a bond buying programme in the summer and or autumn of 2020 they could now have $200m free cash in the bank in stead of $85m. More than enough for further work on Lancaster or even possibly saving the Lincoln/Warwick licences
So what is the point of all this, its history, water under the bridge. The point is that management still consists of just Maris and Chaffe when decisions have to be made on how to spend the funds now available and I do not have confidence in Chaffe’s ability to make the right decisions.