RE: Covidity RNS29 Mar 2022 09:23
Berm
'Wouldn't the original protocol of dosing with SCOV1 and then boosting the same patients with SCOV2 have given all the data they needed to secure MHRA approval for the UK trial?' - yes most likely, especially as this is a Ph1 trial.
My comment was really with regards to running a trial in the UK and recruitment to that. As we have seen with a number of other covid vaccine trials the MHRA and UK Government are twitchy about what will and won't be approved end game. See the trouble that Valneva etc are going through for their whole virus vaccine trial. They've recently expanded their P3 trial to include VLA2001 vaccine trial to include the same jab but as a booster. Yet have run into hurdles because it's not an approved vaccine and so many countries around the world were refusing to acknowledge that patients on this trial had been vaccinated meaning travel etc was becoming problematic. A significant proportion of patients have ended up leaving the trial, going and getting themselves immunised using AZ, Pfizer/BioNTech etc just so they could travel.
When it comes to running trials, you not only have the patient recruitment demographic to balance, but also the cost of running the trial and the cost to the NHS of hosting that trial. If you're not going to get enough patients to complete the trial, or if it's going to cost the NHS a lot of time, money and man power then you unfortunately will struggle to get things off the ground without a lot of hard work and shoe leather. The last thing any trial manager wants is to go through setting up the trial, getting teams on the ground trained and then the patient demographic changes or dwindles. Hence, this RNS today means that we come into that with data generated from patients who have either already been infected and/or have already been immunised with an already approved vaccine. This opens up many more options for running a successful Ph2 and Ph3 trial to completion in the UK or elsewhere in the world.
So yes, whilst I do believe the original data generated from this trial SCOV1 and SCOV2 could be used in this way, I suspect that by expanding it to cover patients who have already had infections or immunisations using other things, will smooth the passage for getting trials started in the UK once data from this cohort has been collected and interpreted.