focusIR May 2024 Investor Webinar: Blue Whale, Kavango, Taseko Mines & CQS Natural Resources. Catch up with the webinar here.
New proof, a release from the external lawyer of KK
https://www.pgplaw.ru/news/press-releases/yuristy-pepelyaev-grupp-zashchitili-interesy-klienta-v-vs-rf-v-ramkakh-spora-o-ndpi-pri-dobyche-zolo/?ysclid=lq5asnupmg191435909
Screenshot https://ibb.co/vQtFP1C
The last note is on 13.12.2023 (Dec 13).
Finally, it looks like that KK management and lawyers really won this massive multi-courts mining tax dispute factually affecting up to twelve months of 2021-2022 production in the past and all future production. The company has acheived approx. 6% of tax rate (instead of 22-23%) for all metals in the concentrate and can return all higher collections already taken by the tax body in previous periods. The text of the Supreme Court will be ready within the week. But the essense of the decision is already uploaded. https://ibb.co/vQtFP1C
It means "Cancel the decision of the first instance court, the decision (ruling) of the appellate court, the decsion (ruling) of the cassation court and adopt a new judicial act."
Screenshot, I dont know how to translate but it means that all previous desisions of the lower courts, that had been made not in favour of KK, were canceled. Screenshot, i dont know how to translate but it means that all previous desisions of the lower courts, that had been made not in favour of KK, were canceled. https://ibb.co/vQtFP1C
I got a link https://kad.arbitr.ru/Kad/Card?number=%D0%9060-42662%2F2022
The note from the Supreme Court dated 13 Dec. "Overturn the decision of the first instance's court, the decision (ruling) of the appellate court, the decision (ruling) of the cassation court and adopt a new judicial act. Really great achievement of KK.
Read this, it what i said about his certainty. https://www-advgazeta-ru.translate.goog/obzory-i-analitika/veroyatnost-udovletvoreniya-podannoy-v-ekonomkollegiyu-vs-zhaloby-1/?ysclid=lp8obtz6bw131439416&_x_tr_sl=ru&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=wapp
... SKES considered only 1.25% of the complaints received at the meeting, and in the SKGD this figure is even lower. However, as the third pointed out, if a judge of the Economic College referred the complaint for consideration at a meeting, then the probability of its satisfaction is more than 90%.
Yes, as I firstly noted, it's what he says in the end of the article, "Kosvinsky Stone CJSC was transferred to the Judicial Collegium for Economic Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which will certainly entail the use of Krent = 1 for platinum." The case is not finished. I see in the court's site that the session will be on Dec 13.
Yes this lawyer clearly says that tax coefficient will be reverted from 3,5 to 1 for the platinum concentrates. I think his confidence is based on the success rate for complaints transferred to this committee of the supreme court. It is more than 95%.
I've just found this. https://zakon-ru.translate.goog/blog/2023/11/7/novyj_podhod_po_voprosam_nalogooblozheniya_metallov_platinovoj_gruppy_101905?_x_tr_sl=ru&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=ru&_x_tr_pto=wapp
he says in the end that Kosva Stone won the case for the entire industry